It’s no secret that big-as-your-head, goo-filled cookies are trending. But Last Crumb cookies just might be the most sought-after of them all. Not only do their flavors range from upgraded takes on timeless combinations to totally unconventional ones, but acquiring them also requires a bit of forethought, due to their popularity. Their cookie boxes (which cost $140 a pop) operate under a “drop” system, much like some streetwear clothing lines. Instead of ordering whenever, cookie-loving consumers add their names to a waitlist in hopes of snagging a curated box the moment they become available.
If you’re eager to taste what the fuss is all about, you can add your name to the waitlist here. While you wait for your turn to indulge, read on for our definitive ranking of the 12 core Last Crumb cookies, from pretty good to oops, we’re in love.