The 19 Best Cookies to Order Online & Gift Anytime

Name: Supernatural Rainbow Starfetti Sprinkles
Brand: Supernatural
Price: 8 USD

A sweet surprise

By Taryn Pire

•

Published Dec 5, 2023

Additional reporting by

Stephanie Meraz

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and the company may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

Best cookies to order online: A shot of cookies

Levain Bakery

Someone you know probably loves cookies—and we have a sneaking suspicion that person is you. It should come as no surprise that a fresh batch of sweet treats is one of the best gifts you can give, whether you're treating yourself or searching for a last-minute gift idea. But finding time to bake (especially at the eleventh hour) is tough. That's where our list of the best cookies to order online comes in.

Whether you're seeking freshly baked choices in an array of yummy flavors—like black and white and the ever-popular chocolate chip—or beyond-speedy delivery, these are the 19 most delicious options to order online, including gluten-free, keto and vegan cookies from Levain Bakery, Milk Bar, Goldbelly and more.

The Best Cookies to Order Online at a Glance

Gooiest Cookies

Levain Bakery Holiday Tin Cookie Bundle

buy it ($64)

Most Fun Flavors

Milk Bar Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookies

buy it (from $27)

Best Ready-to-Bake Cookie Dough

David’s Cookies Ready-to-Bake Large Cookie Dough

Buy it (~~$66~~; $52)

Most Options

Goldbelly William Greenberg Desserts Famous Giant Black & White Cookies

buy it ($60)

Best Flavor Variety

Mouth Smart Cookie Orange Pistachio Shortbread

buy it ($11)

How We Chose the Best Cookies to Order Online

We used our food team's expertise and asked our editors for their top recommendations to cull a list of buzzy cookie brands that ship efficiently across the country. We also made sure to include a wide range of prices and cookie types on our list.

Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

Levain Bakery

Gooiest Cookies

1. Levain Bakery Holiday Tin Cookie Bundle

Levain Bakery

Perhaps you’ve heard your NYC-dwelling bestie mention this iconic bakery before? A favorite of Manhattanites and PureWow staff (yup, we taste-tested them and have been ordering them nonstop ever since), Levain Bakery makes some of the chunkiest, gooiest cookies around. While you can choose between various cookies and gift sets, we think the Holiday Tin Cookie Bundle, packaged beautifully in a reusable container and filled with eight cookies wrapped in cellophane bags and hand-tied blue ribbons, can't be beat. For one, you have several assortments to choose from, whether you think they'll love the full holiday assortment or are gluten-free or vegan. Most importantly, the cookies will arrive fresh to your giftee's doorstep at lightning speed, at which point all they have to do is warm them up at 350°F for five to ten minutes to make them melty all over again. Psst, don't sleep on Levain Bakery's caramel coconut chocolate chip that's loaded with coconutty, buttery and caramel-y goodness.

Fast Facts

Shipping: from $12
Delivery: all states except Alaska and Hawaii

buy it ($64)

Milk Bar

Most Fun Flavors

2. Milk Bar Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookies

Milk Bar

Another Big Apple favorite, Milk Bar’s leftover cake scraps-turned-truffles, creamy soft serve and, of course, cookies, are just a few go-tos on the menu. The secret ingredient? The cereal milk that Milk Bar’s batters, doughs, icings and ice creams are all mixed with (hence, the name), which gives its treats a uniquely nuanced layer of sweetness. Choose from individual cookie flavors, like corn or confetti, or gift all six varieties by ordering an assorted tin instead.

Fast Facts

Shipping: $18 to $30
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it (from $27)

best cookies to order online QVC David’s Cookies

QVC

Best Ready-to-Bake Cookie Dough

3. David’s Cookies Ready-to-Bake Large Cookie Dough

David’s Cookies

Don’t skimp on this ready-to-bake cookie dough from David's Cookies. You’ll receive a box of 72 1.5-ounce pieces of delectable dough that can be stored in the freezer, then baked in batches for your friends and family to enjoy at your holiday bash. As for the flavors, the box comes with a combo of 36 chocolate chunk cookie dough pieces plus your choice of one additional cookie flavor, such as Choco Chunk, Lemon Cooler and S’mores, to name a few, for the remaining 36 pieces. One reviewer raves, “Oh my were they scrumptious, tender, melted in your mouth and so tasty! We tried to hold back eating more—wait a week or so—but wow we couldn’t. My kids kept asking for more and then they were gone.” The nearly 7-pound box will arrive within two days of shipment with dry ice to preserve the freshness of your goodies.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free for all states except Alaska and Hawaii
Delivery: all U.S. states

Buy it (~~$66~~; $52)

Goldbelly

Most Options

4. Goldbelly William Greenberg Desserts Famous Giant Black & White Cookies

Goldbelly

Shopping for someone with a sweet tooth? We suggest turning to Goldbelly, since they have endless options to choose from. From massive molasses cookies made in Texas to New York’s infamous black and white cookies (our personal pick!), there are hundreds of purveyors across the United States to shop on Goldbelly (like Cookie Dō, The Baked Bear and Big Fat Cookie) for freshly baked, delicious goodies that will be delivered right to your loved one’s door.

Fast Facts

Shipping: varies by location
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it ($60)

Best cookies to order online: An assortment of cookies

Mouth

Best Flavor Variety

5. Mouth Smart Cookie Orange Pistachio Shortbread

Mouth

Mouth is a one-stop shop for all types of food gifts. We're talking everything from cheese and cocktail mixers to an ample selection of cookies and desserts. They offer seasonal flavors, like chocolate peppermint, plus classic stalwarts, like triple ginger. They even have gluten- and dairy-free options. TLDR: Come to Mouth if you want a wide range of options and unique flavors, like these orange pistachio shortbread cookies.

Fast Facts

Shipping: varies by product
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it ($11)

Sugarwish

Most Impressive Packaging

6. Sugarwish Cookie Variety Box

Sugarwish

If you’re in search of high quality desserts (like, melt-in-your-mouth, straight-out-of-the-oven, good) Sugarwish is the place to go. Each cookie is individually wrapped to preserve its flavor and freshness. Just pick the box size and let your giftee choose from up to 12 flavors, like stuffed chocolate caramel pretzel, stuffed peanut butter Nutella, white chocolate macadamia nut and stuffed red velvet.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it (from $25)

Mrs. Fields

Best Chocolate Chip Cookies

7. Mrs. Fields Two Dozen Cookie Basket

Mrs. Fields

When it comes to cookies, Mrs. Fields is the undisputed queen of chocolate chip. That’s because the brand uses huge chocolate chunks in every made-to-order batch, so that each bite you take will be full of cocoa-laced goodness. Needless to say, a package of them—or Mrs. Fields’ smorgasbord of chocolate chip cookie cakes and gourmet cookie towers—are bound to make your cookie-obsessed friends very, very happy.

Fast Facts

Shipping: varies by location
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it ($65)

Doughp

Best Edible Cookie Dough

8. Doughp Best Seller Pack

Doughp

If your friend is the type to eat half the cookie dough before it’s even popped in the oven, Doughp is their match made in cookie heaven. Each of the company's pints of raw cookie dough is egg-free and made with treated flour, so they can get their fix without the risk. With a stamp of approval from Shark Tank investors, this company allows you to build your own pack from options like Ride or Die (chocolate chip) or Brownie Beast (brownie and chocolate chip. If you don't know what they'll like, just go with the best-seller pack for good measure.

Fast Facts

Shipping: from $8
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it (from ~~$36~~; $30)

Partake

Best Allergy-Friendly Cookies

9. Partake 4-Box Variety Pack

Partake

Allergy-ridden eaters, rejoice! Vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free and baked without many of today’s top food allergens, Partake’s cookie packs were born from a mother’s frustration after her daughter was diagnosed with severe food allergies, leaving her with minimal snacking options. Today, they make allergy-friendly goods in flavors such as crunchy birthday cake, soft-baked double chocolate, and traditional chocolate chip, so even your friend with the most severe dietary restrictions can enjoy them.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free with Amazon Prime
Delivery: all U.S. states

~~$25~~; $21 at amazon

best cookies to order online HighKey Snickerdoodle

Amazon

Best Keto-Friendly Cookies

10. HighKey Keto Cookies Variety Pack

HighKey

If your fitness buff of a best friend is currently doing the whole keto thing, you may think that a giant container of cookies is off limits. However, HighKey’s assortment of sweet treats and savory snacks are low in carbs and sugar, so they can get their fix without totally blowing their goals. Try the assortment with chocolate chip, snickerdoodle and brownie bite varieties on for size, or keep it simple with vanilla shortbread. While we could tell they weren't packed with sugar and additives, we were seriously impressed with their flavor when we tried them.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free with Amazon Prime
Delivery: all U.S. states

from $15 at amazon

Best cookies to order online: A box of Harry & David cookies

Harry and David

Most Gift-Worthy Cookies

11. Harry & David Classic Signature Cookie Gift Basket

Harry and David

Harry & David has every kind of edible gift you can imagine, including a plethora of cookies. They offer all the classics (think raspberry shortbread and artisanal macarons), along with unique picks, like peach galettes and Belgian chocolate salted caramel cookies.

Fast Facts

Shipping: varies based on location
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it (from $55)

Best cookies to order online: Multicolored cookies

Cheryl's Cookies

Best for Frosting Lovers

12. Cheryl’s Cookies Celebration Cookie Pail

Cheryl's Cookies

Cheryl’s Cookies has every kind of flavor you can imagine, so you’re sure to find something, even for your relative who turns their nose up at chocolate. The brand is most famous for its decadent buttercream frosting, which is just the ticket when you're looking to break out of a chocolate chip rut. There’s even a sprinkle decorating kit, complete with plain cookies, sprinkles and a tub of icing, so the giftee can make their batch to suit their taste.

Fast Facts

Shipping: from $10
Delivery: all U.S. states

buy it ($45)

best cookies to buy online Barnetts Gourmet Biscotti Chocolates Box

Amazon

Best for Chocolate Lovers

13. Barnett’s Gourmet Biscotti Chocolates Box

Barnett's

Who knew cookies could be this elegant? These chocolate-covered sandwich treats from Barnett's are delicious, yes, but the four tasty biscotti flavors (chocolate craisin, chocolate chip, caramel chip, nut crunch, almond crunch and cookie crunch) and pretty toppings of sprinkles, crushed peppermint, dried fruit and chopped nuts really take things to a whole new level. Wash them down with a cup of cold milk or a mug of hot coffee.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free with Amazon Prime
Delivery: all U.S. states

$40 at amazon

Insomnia Cookies

Best for Late-Night Snacking

14. Insomnia Cookies 12 Classic Cookie Gift Box

Insomnia Cookies

If you were a college student in the 2000s, odds are you’ve heard of Insomnia Cookies (and eaten dozens of their sweet confections). Gaining fame among coeds for delivering boxes of warm cookies to dorms into the early hours of the morning, the brand’s treats are about as gooey and chewy as they get. And now, you don’t have to be cramming for a final to enjoy them: This joint will deliver its famed goods, in flavors ranging from birthday cake to double chocolate mint, to any location in the United States. (They have a few vegan flavors too, BTW.)

Fast Facts

Shipping: free for orders $75 and up
Delivery: all states except Alaska and Hawaii

buy it (from $35)

Deux

Best Vegan Cookie Dough

15. Deux Brownie Batter

Deux

Allow us to introduce you to Deux, a line of vegan, gluten-free, raw cookie doughs that double as a wellness snack. Whether you eat it straight out of the jar or roll it into balls to bake, Deux's dough is mixed with high-quality ingredients, like zinc for immune support, maca for a positive mood boost and ashwagandha to aid in stress relief. Popular flavors include s'mores, buttercream sugar cookie and cinnamon roll.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free shipping on purchases $38 and up
Delivery: all states except Alaska and Hawaii

buy it ($16)

Best cookies to order online: Three green packs of Tate's cookies

Amazon

Best Thin Cookies

16. Tate's Bakeshop Cookies Variety Pack

Tate’s

Crispy and crunchy, yet light as air and melt-in-your-mouth good, Tate's cookies are the kind that you're not going to want to put down once you start eating them. And the list of flavors is nothing to scoff at either: vegan vanilla maple and lemon are just a few of our favorites, but you can never go wrong with the brand's cult-favorite chocolate chip. Start with this assortment of oatmeal raisin, chocolate chip walnut and more.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free with Amazon Prime
Delivery: all U.S. states

$21 at amazon

best cookies to order online: granny bella's cookie assortment

Amazon

Best Homestyle Cookies

17. Granny Bella’s Chocolate Cookie Gift Baskets

Granny Bella

If you're searching for a place to find sweet treats that taste as good as grandma's, then Granny Bella's is the choice for you. Every batch is handmade and given the stamp of approval by Granny Bella's grandkiddos, so you know they're tasty (even to picky eaters). Better yet, she doesn't just stick to traditional flavors, so if you're looking to snag something outside of the box, like jelly thumbprints, marble shortbread or delightfully crunchy poppy seed cookies, this spread will deliver (both figuratively and literally).

Fast Facts

Shipping: free with Amazon Prime
Delivery: all U.S. states

$27 at amazon

Best cookies to order online: A tin of Matilde Vicenzi cookies

Amazon

Best Imported Cookies

18. Matilde Vicenzi Roma Cookie Tin

Matilde Vicenzi

You may not be able to hop a flight to Rome, but you can certainly take your tastebuds abroad in the meantime. Matilde Vicenzi offers tins of authentic Italian confections that you can order by the dozen. Each one is filled with traditional Italian puff pastries, cream-filled cookies, shortbread, flaky Danishes and more, so you can have a true international nosh right from your own kitchen.

Fast Facts

Shipping: free with Amazon Prime
Delivery: all U.S. states

$35 at amazon

best cookies to order online Supernatural Rainbow Starfetti Sprinkles

Amazon

Best for DIY Decorating

19. Supernatural Rainbow Starfetti Sprinkles

Supernatural

So, your friend has a favorite cookie dough recipe, but needs help in the decorating department. Hook them up with coconut sugar, sprinkles, frostings and food colorings from Supernatural. Free of preservatives, chemicals and artificial colors, the brand's cookie toppings are vegan, gluten-free, allergy-friendly and made with plant-based ingredients. Might we suggest assembling a gift basket with picks from their shop and your favorite ready-to-bake cookie dough?

Fast Facts

Shipping: free with Amazon Prime
Delivery: all U.S. states

$8 at amazon

Taryn Pire

Food Editor

Taryn Pire is PureWow’s food editor and has been writing about all things delicious since 2016. She’s developed recipes, reviewed restaurants and investigated food trends at...

read full bio

Stephanie Meraz

Associate Fashion Commerce Editor

Stephanie Meraz is PureWow’s Associate Fashion Commerce Editor. Stephanie is a natural savant in the fashion, beauty, and dating & relationships beats. She has over 22+ years...

read full bio

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.