This Is What a $15K Kitchen Before & After Looks Like

Anybody remember “the chokey” from Matilda? Well, that’s the closest cultural touchstone I can find to describe my kitchen before I renovated it: dingy, claustrophobic and beyond dated. With a hyper-ambitious five-week timeline and a firm budget that I knew would require some creative stretching, I embarked on a soup-to-nuts transformation—with no prior reno experience. 

Love a dramatic before-and-after moment? Scroll on and learn how my sweet little “Brooklyn farmhouse kitchen” came to be. 

5 Mistakes I Made While renovating My Kitchen

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen before
Courtesy of Grace Beuley Hunt

The Before

Yeesh. As you can see, there was a lot wrong with this space: The clunky, room-shrinking maple cabinets, the icky linoleum counters, the general lack of storage space, the fridge in front of the only window.  (Why???) I had my work cut out for me. 

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen rendering
Courtesy of Grace Beuley Hunt

The Plan

First things first: I hand-sketched a new a floorplan and asked a friend to make a rendering on Illustrator. My punch list? Install new cupboards, move the sink under the window and add a dishwasher, and replace all counters, backsplash, lighting and appliances. (Casual.) While I generally swoon for a colorful kitchen, I decided to go with a whitewashed color story here, since white is the best space-enlarging trick in the book. Here’s what I changed: 

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 1
Malcolm Hunt

1. Woodwork

With tiny dimensions and no room in the budget to pull a Joanna Gaines and knock down walls, I knew we needed as much storage as humanly possible. Read: Custom, ceiling-high cabinets, an open shelving feature and new lowers to create an L shape. To complicate matters, the apartment is pre-war and has wavy original plaster walls—which necessitated extra on-site fitting and trimming work. I chose simple, flat-face door fronts and worked with a family friend as my builder to keep costs down, but cabinets are like mattresses—good ones are a super-important investment and they’re gonna cost ya

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 8
Malcolm Hunt

2. Plumbing

One of the biggest functional improvements was moving the sink to underneath the window—and popping in an adjacent 18-inch dishwasher. I was anticipating a heavy invoice for plumbing work, but was pleased to learn these changes only cost $500. As for the aesthetics of my new plumbing setup, I had my heart set on a white porcelain farmhouse sink. I searched high and low for a model with apartment dimensions and couldn’t find one anywhere. That is, until I found this 23.5 inch cutie. (Hot tip: Home decor megasite Wayfair has a huge and amazing home renovation section.) I finished this country sink with a satin finish, gooseneck faucet

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 7
Malcolm Hunt

3. Counters

For my countertops, I wanted something bright, white and airy that I wouldn’t have to worry about from a care perspective. The obvious choice? Quartz. My builder had a relationship with a local stone yard and was able to get a glossy white quartz slab expedited. I had always associated quartz with being a somewhat budget-friendly counter choice—so I was pretty shocked by our $2,600 tab. 

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 2
Malcolm Hunt

4. Backsplash

While I wanted to go with easy-upkeep, man-made material on the countertops for utility reasons (hi, constant wear-and-tear), classic Carrara marble is my dream kitchen material. So I brought in some of that luxe natural texture via the less-abused backsplash instead. How gorgeous are these XL subway tiles

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 5
Malcolm Hunt

5. Pantry

The kitchen features a shallow wall cutout in the back corner, which was imperative for storage—but super awkward-looking. Originally we noodled on installing a custom pull-out pantry, but to save money, I had my builder add some interior cubbies and hooks, and then I hung a simple linen bistro curtain—which encloses cleaning supplies, bulk items and various hardware odds and ends.  

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 9
Malcolm Hunt

6. Hardware

I know, I know—mixed metals are the order of the hour. But I really wanted a classic space, and I didn’t feel like the small footprint could stomach too much experimentation. I streamlined the room and tied in the appliances with these classic satin nickel knobs and pulls

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 3
Malcolm Hunt

7. Appliances

(Not-so) fun fact: Mini appliances are way more expensive than larger, standardized models. I had to quadruple my appliances estimate to account for a built-in 24-inch fridge, a mini 18-inch dishwasher and a 24-inch stove and blower. We had originally wanted to install an over-range microwave, but they were a rarity and crazy-expensive. Who knew? 

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 4
Malcolm Hunt


My best advice? Work with someone you trust. Open, comfortable dialogue with your builder is key to getting what you want in the long run. Also, keep it classic. There are so many options when it comes to kitchen design, but by staying simple and timeless, I didn’t get overwhelmed by choice, I kept on schedule and I expect that my design will look current for decades to come. Lastly, double your budget. Honestly, nothing is perfect when it comes to construction and all those little adjustments and extra hours will add up more than you can imagine. 

So there you have it: A lot of money and life lessons later, I have a kitchen I truly love to call home. And can you really put a price on that? (Well yes, $15,000, but I’m trying to forget about that.)

brooklyn farmhouse kitchen 6
Malcolm Hunt


Custom cabinetry: Quinn Custom Woodwork LLC 
Farmhouse sink: Wayfair
Knobs: Wayfair
Pulls: Wayfair
Faucet: Wayfair
Backsplash tile: Wayfair 
Ceiling fixture: Lamps Plus 


Home Editor

From 2014-2019 Grace Beuley Hunt held the role of Home Editor covering interior design, styling, trends and more.