Does the ‘Firefly Lane’ Cast Look Familiar? Here’s Where You’ve Seen Them Before

From Sarah Heigl to Jolene Purdy.

firefly lane cast netflix
Courtesy of Netflix

Now that we’ve watched both seasons of Firefly Lane (the release date for the final batch of episodes was way back on April 27, 2023), we decided to compile a foolproof guide to the cast. That way, when you’re binge-watching the episodes on Netflix, you’ll have a one-stop shop to answer the age-old question: Where else have I seen [insert actor’s name]?

Here’s everything we know about the Firefly Lane cast.

firefly lane cast katherine heigl

1. Katherine Heigl as Tully Hart

  • What else she’s been in: Grey’s Anatomy, The Ugly Truth, 27 Dresses, Knocked Up, Life as We Know It, Doubt

After starring as Izzie Stevens in Grey’s Anatomy, Katherine Heigl went on to play Samantha Wheeler in Suits following Meghan Markle’s departure from the show.

firefly lane cast beau garrett sarah chalke
Courtesy of Netflix

2. Sarah Chalke as Kate Mularkey

  • What else she’s been in: The 'Bu, Scrubs, Mad Love, Cougar Town, How I Met Your Mother, Roseanne, Friends from College, Rick and Morty

Yes, Sarah Chalke played Dr. Elliot Reid in Scrubs and Stella Zinman in How I Met Your Mother. But did you know she also voiced Beth in Rick and Morty?

firefly lane cast beau garrett
Courtesy of Netflix

3. Beau Garrett as Cloud

  • What else she’s been in: Criminal Minds: Suspect Behavior, Glee, Longmire, Girlfriends’ Guide to Divorce, The Good Doctor

In addition to joining the Firefly Lane cast, Beau Garrett portrayed Phoebe in Girlfriends’ Guide to Divorce and Jessica Preston in The Good Doctor.

firefly lane cast ben lawson

4. Ben Lawson as Johnny Ryan

  • What else he’s been in: Covert Affairs, Don’t Trust the B---- in Apartment 23, Designated Survivor, 13 Reasons Why, The Good Place.

How could we forget about Ben Lawson’s film credits, which include No Strings Attached and Bombshell?

firefly lane cast brandon jay mclaren

5. Brandon Jay Mclaren as Travis

  • What else he’s been in: She’s the Man, Power Rangers S.P.D., The Killing, Girlfriends’ Guide to Divorce, UnREAL, Ransom

Rom-com fans probably recognize Brandon Jay McLaren from She’s the Man, where he played Toby. “Screw you guys. I hate high school.”

firefly lane cast alissa skovbye

6. Alissa Skovbye as Teenage Tully

  • What else she’s been in: The Man in the High Castle, When Calls the Heart, Smallville, Supernatural, Fringe, Once Upon a Time, Falling Skies

At age 21, Alissa “Ali” Skovbye already has a stacked resume. But her most noteworthy roles were Annie Sanders in The Man in the High Castle and Becky in When Calls the Heart.

firefly lane cast roan curtis
Courtesy of Netflix

7. Roan Curtis as Teenage Kate

  • What else she’s been in: Shut Eye, The Magicians, Before I Fall, Secrets of a Gold Digger Killer

Roan Curtis played Sylvia in The Magicians and Emma in Shut Eye, but she’s also had guest appearances in The L Word, Supernatural, Charmed and The Good Doctor.

firefly lane cast yael yurman
Courtesy of Netflix

8. Yael Yurman as Marah

  • What else she’s been in: The Man in the High Castle, To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before, Once Upon a Time

In addition to shows like Sacred Lies and Snowpiercer, Yael Yurman also portrayed Anastasia in Once Upon a Time. Alexa, please play “Once Upon a December.”

firefly lane cast Jolene Purdy
Courtesy of Netflix

9. Jolene Purdy as Justine

  • What else she’s been in: Orange Is the New Black, The White Lotus, WandaVision, Superstore, The Magicians

She played Lani in one episode of The White Lotus season 1.

firefly lane cast India de Beaufort
Courtesy of Netflix

10. India de Beaufort as Charlie

  • What else she’s been in: Night Court, Slumberland, Kimi, Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist

She currently stars as Olivia Moore on NBC’s Night Court.

firefly lane cast Brendan Taylor mutt
Courtesy of Netflix

11. Brendan Taylor as Mutt

  • What else he’s been in: Supernatural, Fargo, Noelle, The Arrangement

Although he specializes in TV movies, he also played Pierre in Fargo.

firefly lane cast Ignacio Serricchio Danny Diaz
Courtesy of Netflix

12. Ignacio Serricchio as Danny Diaz

  • What else he’s been in: The Wedding Ringer, General Hospital, Lost in Space, Bones, Young and the Restless

We could go on and on about his extensive resume, but he’s best known for playing Diego in General Hospital, Alex Chaves in Young and the Restless and Don West in Lost in Space.

firefly lane cast Chelah Horsdal margie

13. Chelah Horsdal as Margie

  • What else she’s been in: The Man in the High Castle, Star Trek: Discovery, Hell on Wheels, When Calls the Heart

Prior to becoming a Firefly Lane cast member, Chelah Horsdal made a name for herself as a TV regular.

firefly lane cast Jason McKinnon sean
Courtesy of Netflix

14. Jason McKinnon as Sean

  • What else he’s been in: Shattered, Wonder, Falling Skies, Night at the Museum

While he had small roles in several big films—like Wonder and Night at the Museum—his resume mainly consists of TV movies.

Get the latest entertainment news sent to your inbox by subscribing here.

A Complete Guide to All the ‘Firefly Lane’ Season 2 Spoilers


Senior Editor

Greta Heggeness is a California-based editor at PureWow and has been writing about entertainment since 2015. She covers everything from awards shows to exclusive celebrity...