Whether the 15-year-old you’re shopping for is into beauty, theater, sports or sleeping (somehow it’s always sleeping), finding a gift they won’t roll their eyes at can feel like an impossible assignment. (Yup, our niece actually asked us to include the gift receipt with the present we got her last year.) So, to avoid disappointments, this year we went to the experts—high schoolers themselves—and quizzed 53 of them, from ages 13 to 19, about their holiday wish lists. And here's what we learned: It all comes down to quality, style and cool factor. In other words, anything that makes them stand out.
If your niece goes from the classroom to practice, scoop up Lululemon's viral Align top. Or, if they've been tapping into their artsy side, why not get them an easel set? After all, it's not about how much you spend—it's about whether it aligns with their personality. So to get you started, here are 67 gifts for every teen personality—from gamers to beauty enthusiasts to the astrology-obsessed.