Whether we’re curious about the newest rom-com or eager to get hot takes on a psychological thriller that’s breaking the internet, we can always count on Rotten Tomatoes to help us figure out what’s really worth watching. In fact, some of the best movies that we’ve seen were due to the site’s thoughtful critic reviews. But while most of these reviewers typically have an eye for great films, there have been quite a few cases where their ratings left us confused.
Unfortunately, some of the most iconic films wound up with surprisingly low scores—and we’re not talking about films that are so bad that they’re good. We’re talking Hocus Pocus, Home Alone 2 and Beaches (yep, we’re just as shocked as you are). Read on for more movies that we absolutely love, regardless of what the critics say.