Does Hannah Ann Win ‘The Bachelor?’ Venmo Seems to Suggest So

Venmo: It makes splitting dinner with your friends easier and, interestingly enough, is a breeding ground for The Bachelor winner theories. Allow us to explain.

It all started during Colton Underwood’s season of the hit dating show when one brilliant fan decided to check out his Venmo account and realized that he and Cassie Randolph were friends on the payment platform. After Underwood and Randolph formally announced they were together, the 28-year-old former football player gave Twitter user @clur19 “major props” for figuring their romance out with such creative tactics.

Now, fans are using this tried-and-true theory to figure out who wins Peter Weber’s season of The Bachelor. Apparently, Hannah Ann is the only remaining contestant with a private Venmo account, which definitely seems suspicious. (As you’ll notice, the internet also seems to think that Madison is the next Bachelorette, but we’ll discuss that at some other point.)

It’s also worth noting that as of January 6, Hannah Ann and Weber, 28, were friends on Venmo, according to one fan.

However, this editor can confirm that’s no longer the case. (Yes, I avidly check Weber’s Vemo and am still waiting for him to approve my friend request. No biggie.)

The last piece of evidence? Apparently, Hannah Ann posed for an Instagram photo with the same golf bag that Peter has.

For reference, here’s the photo of Hannah Ann playing caddy. 

And here’s a screenshot from Weber’s Instagram Stories of him at the driving range. 

peter weber golf bag

Sure, the bags are similar, but it’s really anyone’s guess if they’re the same. Callaway is a popular brand, after all. Regardless, it’s fun to theorize, isn’t it?

Now, excuse me while I obsessively refresh my Venmo feed.


Cat mom, yogi, brunch enthusiast

Lex is an LA native who's deeply obsessed with picnics, Slim Aarons, rosé, Hollywood history and Joan Didion. She joined PureWow in early 2017.