These Are the 4 Best Colored Engagements Rings (Inspired by J.Lo, Of Course)

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and the company may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

Yes, we're still screaming at the fact that our favorite early 2000s couple Bennifer—Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck—just got engaged (again). And we're absolutely swooning at the singer's gorgeous green diamond engagement ring. Guys, “Jenny from the Block,” has a colored engagement ring.

Take it in below because, according to Mike Fried (Diamond Pro CEO), “If that is indeed a green diamond, then I am stunned. A green diamond of that size is incredibly rare and would dwarf the value of their previous engagement ring. I would value the ring well over $5 million. It could be worth more than $10 million.”

lynda lopez instagram

Of course, we're giving our partners subtle hints about what we hope to see someday when we open that cute little box (whether it's for an engagement or a just because gift). But since we can't get the exact same ring as J.Lo (sighs), we rounded up four of the best colored engagement rings that are just as stunning.

colored engagement rings brilliant earth
Brilliant Earth

1. Brilliant Earth Colored Diamonds

OK, we're just going to assume that most of us don't have the same bling budget as Ben Affleck, which is why we're here for these Brilliant Earth selects. From a 0.72 Ct. Fancy Yellow Radiant Diamond for $1,630 to a 0.58 Ct. Fancy Pink Round Diamond for a whopping $56,170, there's a colored engagement ring for any and every queen.

colored engagement rings catbird

2. Catbird

If she's a minimalist, she'll appreciate you stepping outside of the box and going for one of Catbird's gemstones, like the vibrant green Spectrum, Solano and Lexie Emerald styles, to name a few. And if you really want to go all out, get two simple silhouettes for her to stack on her finger.

colored engagement rings blue nile
Blue Nile

3. Blue Nile

There are thousands of colored diamonds that are available in various carats, shapes and shades on Blue Nile, which is why it's one of our favorite places to shop for engagement rings. Plus, prices start at $512 and go as high as $1,930,779, so you should be able to find one within your budget. Personally, we're obsessed with the 0.33-Carat Intense Yellow-orange Pear Shaped Diamond. Everything from its sleek pear shape to its gorgeous untraditional color sets it apart from most rings.

colored engagement rings david yurman
Saks Fifth Avenue

4. David Yurman

Her jaw will drop when you present her with a little David Yurman box revealing a one-of-kind ring. The famed jewelry designers' colored options range from $450 to $10,000, so they also make good promise rings or birthday gifts. Like this Châtelaine Heart Ring. The Morganite orange and pink gemstone is obviously the center of attention here, but the 18K rose gold band definitely takes things up a notch.

DS Headshot
Destinee Scott

Assistant Sales and Deals Editor

Destinee Scott is PureWow’s Assistant Sales and Deals Editor. She’s been chasing sales and deals for a decade and knows a good one when she sees one for fashion, home, beauty...
read full bio