From Jack’s death to Kevin’s struggle with addiction, This Is Us never fails to keep us on our toes. And with season three right around the corner, series creator Dan Fogelman has sparked a flurry of fan theories about a skeleton in the Pearson extended-family closet.
It all started when Fogelman shared a sneak peek photo of Randall’s (Sterling K. Brown) late biological father, William (Ron Cephas Jones), holding an infant that’s presumably Randall. The Emmy winner casually captioned the snap, “Season 3. Brace yourselves,” but fans couldn’t help but notice some discrepancies in the pic.