When it comes to towels, most of us fall into one of two camps: You either invest in the good stuff—the plush, hotel-quality kind that makes drying off feel like an act of self-care—or you grab whatever is on sale and call it a day. But the real question is, do the so-called “luxury” towels actually live up to the hype? After you’ve put them through the ringer (literally) of daily use, multiple wash cycles and questionable bathroom ventilation, do they retain that fluffy feel? And are they absorbent, too? Simply put, are they worth the spend, when you have so many other expenses vying for your hard-earned dollar?
To find out, I recruited a handful of PureWow editors—myself included—to put some of the internet’s most popular plush towels to the test. Think: hotel-caliber towels from Parachute, thick yet quick-drying options from Brooklinen and ultra-soft sets from Cozy Earth. While plenty of options looked good on the rack, only a few earned top marks for the qualities that really count: softness, absorbency, durability and how fast they actually dry between uses. So below, find nine plush towels that were worth the splurge—and which ones left us hanging (pun intended).