Tested and Reviewed: Does The Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max Live Up to The Hype?

The Alexa compatibility certainly does…

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

amazon firestick hero 1
Original Image by Candace Davison
  • Ease of Use: 20/20
  • Functionality: 19/20
  • Design & Features: 18/20
  • Performance: 18/20
  • Value: 17/20

TOTAL: 92/100

As someone who recently retired their dusty old Roku in favor of the Hisense CanvasTV (yes, the one with the matte frame that looks like art), I decided I was done with streaming sticks for good. Which is why, when we decided to test the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max—a $60 device that claims to make any HDMI-equipped screen feel brand new—I passed the reins to someone still living in the pre-refresh era: Candace Davison, PureWow’s VP of Editorial Content, who tested it on her 13-year-old smart TV.

Here, find her full, unbiased feedback

Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

First Impressions

“Phew, this is delightfully simple and intuitive to set up,” Candace said, noting that “there weren’t a ton of cords and cables, and if you needed them, there was a very straightforward, visual guide to setting up the Firestick. It couldn’t be easier, even if you’re not tech-savvy.” In the box: “You receive the Firestick device (which is basically the size of a USB drive you can plug into the back of your TV), along with triple-A batteries, a power cable, adaptor, remote and HDMI extender cable, in case your TV is mounted on the wall so closely that you can’t easily plug in the Firestick.”

Initially, she was especially skeptical that it would work with her setup. “I was worried that my ancient TV—it’s about 13 years old!—wouldn’t be compatible, even though it’s technically a ‘smart TV.’” According to the brand, all you need is high-speed wifi and an HDMI port. Still, she had reservations, though she was pleased to report that “it connected easily and quickly.” Previously, she had been casting everything through her phone and Google Chromecast, which was “very slow to load.” When she fired up the Firestick, she expected a similar experience. “Thankfully, it wasn’t. The TV switches between apps quickly, without the laggy load time I’d been experiencing in the past.”

Streaming Felt Like an Instant Upgrade

“Right away, I logged into YouTube, Netflix and Amazon Prime Video and started streaming different shows and videos,” Candace said. “The picture quality was crisp and clear, with less load time than I was used to in the past…It was like I’d upgraded my entire TV, just by adding the Firestick.”

And for someone who streams YouTube often? “I really loved that the remote has voice control. It makes it so much easier to search for what you want, rather than clicking one letter at a time.”

Art Mode Is Fun, But It's Most Impressive If You Have the Right TV

amazon

One of the big draws of the Firestick is that it has an Ambient Experience mode—which some call "art mode," that essentially acts as a screensaver for your TV, displaying your choice of art or high-resolution images. If you own a Samsung Frame TV or similar design (or DIY'ed a frame to go around your television), it can make your screen look like a work of art when you're not actively watching a show.

"With my older, thicker TV, the feature just kind of looked like a screensaver," Davison says. "It was nice, but I wasn't fooling anyone."

The feature also includes an AI-based art generator, where you can use the voice commands to ask it to create an image for you that you can display. "It's fun, especially since the results are all over the place," Davison explains. "The generator returns a few options for your request, though they all tend to fall in that uncanny valley of being close but not quite what you're looking for, and—when it comes to people and animals—a touch creepy."

firestick art mode test
What Ambient Experience Looks Like on an Ancient TV (Photo: Candace Davison)

Standout Features

amazon

“This seems minor,” Candace added, “but given that very few electronics come with the outlet adapter anymore, I was grateful this one did. I didn’t have to go out and buy another—or sacrifice part of an existing charger—to set up the device.” Not to mention that it’s Alexa-compatible. “The Alexa voice remote has wound up being my favorite feature. I typically prefer Google Assistant to Alexa in terms of smart speakers, because I feel like Alexa constantly mishears me (seriously, am I a chronic mumbler or something?!)...but with this remote, the translation has consistently been clear, and it converts my speech to text quicker than the Roku [I use] downstairs does.”

She also noted that, “This device is great for the tech-averse…My parents bought a Roku-enabled smart TV, just because they were paranoid about dealing with dongles and tech that wasn’t already baked in, but this they could easily handle.” Plus, “the visual instructions make it easy to follow. The only hangup is your TV and home’s compatibility. High-speed wifi and an HDMI port are crucial here, or it won’t work.”

Final Thoughts

What We Like

  • HDMI extender makes wall-mounted setup easy
  • Noticeably faster streaming on older TVs
  • Crisp, high-res picture with minimal load time
  • Voice search on remote actually works

What We Don't Like

  • Requires a strong Wi-Fi connection
  • Will only work if your TV has an HDMI port
  • No volume/mute buttons on some older Alexa remotes (depends on version)

Amazon

“Honestly, I went into this wary that there would be a bunch of bloatware and Amazon ads and pop-ups that’d make the Firestick annoying to use. Thankfully, that wasn’t the case,” Davison wraps up. “It’s offered such a clear, crisp picture and has been such an upgrade from casting my phone to my TV that I can’t see myself going back.”

To that end, she adds: “I was on the verge of selling or donating the TV, because it’d gotten so laggy. It turns out this was just the upgrade I needed to have it feeling like a brand-new TV. Normally, new tech on an old device does just the opposite, so this was a very pleasant surprise.”

Fast Facts

  • What’s Included: Fire TV Stick 4K Max, Alexa Voice Remote, HDMI extender, USB power cable, power adapter, AAA batteries
  • Compatibility: Works with any TV that has an HDMI port and access to high-speed Wi-Fi
  • Voice Control: Alexa-enabled remote with built-in microphone for voice commands
  • Streaming Services: Netflix, Prime Video, YouTube, Disney+, HBO Max, and more

profile pic WP

Associate Editor

  • Writes across all lifestyle verticals, including relationships and sex, home, finance, fashion and beauty
  • More than five years of experience in editorial, including podcast production and on-camera coverage
  • Holds a dual degree in communications and media law and policy from Indiana University, Bloomington

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.