If your closet is anything like ours, it contains at least one pair of jeans you’ve been meaning to donate, another that only fits after a very specific workout and one pair you swear you’ll wear once the weather cools down. Then there’s the pair. The jeans you reach for without thinking. The ones that somehow work with everything. So we posed an impossible question to our team: If you could only keep one pair of jeans, which would it be?
We found the answers say as much about personal style as they do about denim itself. Some editors swear by rigid, vintage-inspired pairs that only get better with age. Others refuse to give up the cropped hem. But it's no surprise all of them feature cotton as the main material: The natural fiber is durable, easy to care for and built to last, which is exactly what you want from jeans you plan on wearing into the ground—especially as we head into the fall. Plus, unlike synthetic fibers, cotton doesn’t shed microplastics. Fashion loves declaring a new jean every five minutes, but the best pair is often the one that has nothing to do with the moment. Ahead, meet the jeans our editors wear on repeat.








