Each year, along with the turning of the leaves and the sipping of the pumpkin spice latte, it happens: Stylish women shop Amazon for a coat that hits the sweet spot of style, utility and affordability. Yes, cute, cozy and (relatively) cheap are what you want in a winter coat, and as sure as the first snowfall, one coat will outsell the others. A few years ago it was the Orolay oversized parka; last year, the Daily Ritual Teddy Bear Fleece Jacket was uber-popular. So for the rest of year and into 2023, what will the chilly winds of fashion blow to our door in a package emblazoned with a big Amazon swoosh? We asked three stylish editors—our commerce editor, fashion editor and associate editor—to pick the coat that’s going to hit big this year. Here are their predictions: