Madewell’s Fall Collection Is the Stylish Hill I’ll Die On—Here’s Everything I Tried (and Loved)

It had me at barn coat

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

Madewell Fall 2026 Try-On: Original photos by Stephanie Meraz
Original photos by Stephanie Meraz

As a fashion editor, I live by the unspoken rule of refreshing my wardrobe with each new season, and there’s no better collection than a fall one. From browns and burgundies to barn coats and knitwear, the new pieces are full of texture, warm colors, prints and everything anyone could ask for. Don’t believe me? Just walk into a Madewell store and you’ll see that the proof is in the pudding…err, clothing. That’s what happened to me when I stopped in to review Madewell’s jeans. Naturally, I couldn’t pass up the chance to try it all on. Below are the Madewell fall pieces I’m itching to add to my wardrobe, from denim dresses and plaid prints to quilted jackets and so much more.

Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

Is it autumn without a waxed barn jacket to complete your outerwear? I didn’t think so. Madewell’s longline version is built for rainy days and blistering winds, thanks to its cotton and nylon blend that keeps the wet away. And I’d be remiss not to mention its cool construction. It may look like a basic brown jacket at first glance, but peer a little closer and you’ll notice oversized utility pockets big enough to fit all the contents of your small purse, along with soft corduroy at the collar and inside the cuff. It’s not the warmest piece of outerwear, but I can see it being my go-to when I need to weather the storm.

Denim dresses like Madewell’s Chrissy are synonymous with autumn—their dark blue wash and thicker fabric is practically made for sipping cider at the farm stand. This mini number takes the cake with its pleated skirt and pinched waist (complete with a flattering tuck) that’s incredibly stretchy and breathable thanks to the elastic bunching at the back. It’s even great for a casual day at the office. I paired it with Madewell’s Greta flats in the most luxe brown suede and the Lexington suede handbag to tie in the cacao notes.

This is your sign to stock up on vibrant, colorful knits before it’s too late. Staples like the Cora sweater, available in six colorways, are perfect for crisp days because they're made from merino wool and yak hair that’ll keep you feeling nice and warm. Here, I opted for a size medium. It’s already designed with an oversized fit and drop shoulders, so if you’re looking for a more true-to-size fit, size down. When you’re not wearing it, try draping it over your shoulders or tying it at your waist in place of a belt for a cool look that’s still polished and put-together.

While you're at it, snag the Holland sweater for a subtly festive option that doesn't scream seasonal. This piece is lighter than the previous knit because it's made from an Italian alpaca-blend yarn that one customer notes is "nice and soft and not too itchy," adding that it's "a little slouchy but not too oversized." Another reviewer points out that while it's "just a tad scratchy and is dry clean only," they love it anyway and confirm that it's a compliment magnet. It's the piece that'll keep you warm without feeling overwhelmingly fluffy or suffocating on your skin—perfect for traveling, layering under thicker coats or stashing in your tote bag for emergencies. I paired it with the brand’s low-rise loose jeans in a size up for a relaxed, comfy outfit.

If a pullover style isn’t your favorite, try this sweet button-up cardigan. You’ll still revel in patterned stripes and cozy warmth courtesy of its 100 percent merino wool. Plus, with a cardigan, there’s always the flexibility to button it closed or leave it unbuttoned over a tank top. Pair it with a dark-wash straight-leg jean like the Madewell pair I’m wearing, and you’ll be ready to take on the day.

The Devon Pants were everywhere I looked in the store—hanging on the racks, folded neatly on the table and even on the mannequin—which is why I knew I had to try them on. Although this collegiate purple stripe is totally out of my element, it was clear these pants are a hit among Madewell customers. I’d even go as far as to call them a non-pajama-pant-pajama pant because they’re drapey, uber-soft and, as one reviewer notes, “truly the most comfortable pants.” (With pockets, might I add!) While I tend to gravitate toward high-rise bottoms, I actually prefer this style's mid-rise fit because it looks a little edgier and more relaxed, especially if you want to dress it up with a sexy, strappy high heel and a sweater. I paired it with the Sophia cardigan in a dark brown colorway and the Greta flats again.

One thing to know about me: I’m a sucker for fleece. Let’s chalk it up to the fuzzy fabric against my skin and the feeling of being wrapped in a blanket, a cozy combination that makes me want to buy every fleece I see. But if I had to choose, Madewell’s version trumps them all for a few reasons. First, I could live in it. As dramatic as that sounds, I truly didn’t want to take it off the moment I pulled it over my head. Second, it’s incredibly well-constructed, from the elastic cuffs to the adjustable hem that lets you cinch it for a cropped, fitted look or leave it loose over layers. Finally, Madewell achieved perfection the second it decided to make it a quarter-zip. Between the retro silhouette and the nostalgic pattern, I feel like I'm wearing my mom’s vintage jacket from the '80s—and I couldn't be happier.

Here’s your sign to invest in a fall jacket that is a little out-there, style-wise. One that pushes your boundaries in color, design and print—just like this quilted number from Madewell. It’s “an awesome jacket for transitional weather,” as one reviewer says, with a light, airy feel, likely thanks to its cotton construction. The fit is cropped and on the boxy side, which I love because it makes it easy to add layers underneath. It’s especially great if you’re looking for a statement piece that instantly zhuzhes up your look. The pops of pattern from the lining are also so good that some customers (myself included) wish it were reversible, but you can’t always have it all.

Don’t underestimate the power of a good tee, like this long-sleeve crewneck from Madewell. Staying true to the striped theme and the burgundy fall palette, it’s the perfect top to replace your usual whites and blacks—you know the ones I’m talking about. I’m guilty of it, too, but sometimes choosing a patterned top that’s just as casual as your regular white T-shirt can make you look a bit more styled with no extra effort. Plus, you won’t skimp on comfort in the slightest; the 100 percent cotton number is soft, roomy and relaxed.

Holiday parties and gatherings are sneaking up on the calendar, which means it's time to stock up on cute blouses—like this ruffle top that’s practically made for the season. The details of the blouson sleeves, ruffles and pintucks alone “look similar to Dôen and Balzac styles [and] at a fraction of the price,” gushed one shopper. Then there’s its lightweight feel. I know investing in an airy, 100 percent cotton top right before winter doesn’t sound like the brightest idea; I’d argue against that notion, especially if you like to wear wool coats, cashmere sweaters and knitted scarves. If you’re anything like me and tend to run sweaty on the regular, you’ll be thanking your lucky stars that you’re wearing a breathable blouse as a base.

With the slightly see-through fabric, you can tastefully sport some really cute bralettes. I finished the look with barrel-leg jeans, ballet flats, and a crossbody bag for a leisurely look, but I’d also love to see this tucked into a velvet mini skirt and knee-high boots.

These aren’t your regular low-rise jeans, people. They’re “cool” jeans. Especially if you opt for the Smoked Claret + Rigid colorway. While I discovered that most of Madewell’s jeans fit true to size, I wish I had sized up in this style because the 100 percent cotton construction is not stretchy or forgiving in the slightest, and I personally like my low-rise to sit, well, low. The inky hue, however, is perfection, and since I like staying true to those autumnal tones, I styled them with the same crewneck I previously tried (see above) in a different color. Then I threw on the Idris suede boots to add a bit of texture and depth.

Plaid dresses and fall go together like warm pancakes and sticky syrup on a Sunday morning. And it’s not every day you find a satin dress cut on the bias for under $200. This thoughtful tailoring prevents fabric from awkwardly puckering at the seams, giving you a flattering drape that flows seamlessly over your silhouette. “I absolutely love this dress…the neck/cut of the neckline and armholes is so flattering while also being comfortable and elegant,” wrote one reviewer. I went for my usual size but found it slightly too loose for my liking, so I’d size down for a more fitted feel. That said, if you have a larger chest, I’d stick to your usual size.


IMG 0045

Stephanie Meraz

Contributing Editor, Commerce

  • Covers all things fashion and shopping
  • Boasts over 23 years of experience as an avid shopper, having secured a personal stylist at Limited Too at the age of four
  • Studied English literature, communications and creative writing at the University of San Diego, and completed the Columbia Publishing Course at Columbia University in New York

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.