In the past three seasons of Netflix’s You, Joe Goldberg—played brilliantly by Penn Badgley—has gone to extreme lengths to win the hearts of his latest obsessions. In the process, the show has offered a glimpse into the mind of this charming sociopath, who has totally shifted our perspective on love and infatuation.
Fortunately, the first half of the fourth season will premiere on February 9, so fans can expect to see more of Joe’s antics as he takes on his newest personality, Professor Jonathan Moore. But if you’re wondering how you’ll fill the Joe-shaped void after flying through the first five episodes, we compiled a list of the 12 best shows like You. Keep reading for the best options on Netflix, Prime Video and more.