The New Twisty Thriller Everyone’s Watching—But Can’t Stop Arguing About

For anyone wondering, All Her Fault isn’t based on a true story but it was inspired by a real moment in the author's life. She once went to pick up her daughter from a playdate only to find the house empty, sparking a panic that eventually inspired the book.

It sounds totally gripping and with all the recent buzz, you’d think it was destined for awards season but the reviews tell a different story. In a nutshell, some viewers are obsessed, while others are less impressed.

Time slammed the series, calling it “absolute nonsense” and saying it’s “so ill-conceived and poorly executed, on so many levels,” while Variety described it as “middling.”

But not everyone feels that way. The Guardian called it “an absolute pleasure to watch” and on Rotten Tomatoes it holds a solid 75 percent average score.

"Absolute must-see. Wild twists and turns, camp, and incredible performances," one person raved. While another shared, "Despite the glowing mainstream reviews...there is nothing new or creative here."

While viewers are on either end of the love-it-hate-it spectrum, there is one thing everyone can agree on. Sarah Snook kills it.