Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk Soulmates Collection Review: What’s Actually Worth the Hype

I haven’t worn a matte lipstick in years, but these new additions just might turn me into a full time convert. The OG Pillow Talk lipsticks are already a hit, so I wasn’t surprised that these were just as flattering on all skin tones. They come in four limited edition shades, and I tested “Dream Talk” (a muted deep mauve hue) and “Love Talk” (a strawberry red shade). They were both high-pigmented, glided nicely on my lips and left a soft matte finish. Each one is formulated with oils and waxes that promise 10-hour wear and non-transferring abilities. Both shades were comfortable for a couple of hours, but like many mattes I’ve tried, they started to feel a bit drying at the end of the day. However, the lipsticks are buildable, so I usually apply more lipstick or a lip balm on top for a moisturizing finish. 

The K.I.S.S.I.N.G lipsticks are a nice contrast to their matte counterparts. They are super moisturizing, lightweight and comfortable to wear all day. They comes in two shades: “Naughty Talk” (a neutral nude shade) and “Kiss Talk” (a dewy pink shade) that complemented my complexion. They’re rich in antioxidants, which are designed to soften and hydrate lips. While Matte Revolution is transfer-proof and long-lasting, these two offered a high-shine, glossy finish. They had more of a sheer texture, so I did need a few swipes to see pigment. The packaging is covered in the brand’s signature gold tube with a pink heart jewel on top, plus hearts inscribed on the actual lipstick and a unique shape that made lining my lips easier. 

This lip gloss is not actually new, but it’s a popular item in the collection that caught my attention. Plumpgasm comes in two shades that complement your complexion, so I reached for the medium to deep shade that features hints of brown, berry and pink. This one doesn’t mess around in the gloss department—my pout never looked so juicy. Seriously—infused with heat and ice technology, collagen and hyaluronic acid, the plumping effect is no joke. It leaves a tingling sensation for a few minutes, leaving a smoother, fuller appearance. I wore it for a couple of hours, and it was still super hydrating and ultra-glossy. Hot tip: I recommend using the Pillow Talk Lip Cheat liner in “Pillow Talk Medium” for a lip combo that will define and enhance your fuller pout.