Latest Episode of ‘The Masked Singer’ Sends Another Contestant Packing & Reveals this Season’s Finalists

masked singer 4

*Warning: Spoilers ahead*

Last week on The Masked Singer, the quarterfinals revealed one of America’s Got Talent’s biggest stars (singer Jackie Evancho) and left us with the top four. But last night, we said farewell to another beloved contestant and found out which three are headed to next week’s finals.

Night Angel started the night off, serenading the panelists (including, guest judge, Jay Pharoah) with Lil Wayne's “How to Love,” followed by Turtle, who showed off his falsetto with sang Nick Jonas’s “Jealous.” Then, Rhino took the stage and performed his rendition of Tim McGraw's “Humble and Kind.” Finally, Frog ended the lineup with Naughty by Nature's “Hip Hop Hooray.”

After the audience and panelists voted for their favorite performances of the night, Nick Cannon announced that it was the end of the road for Rhino, who revealed himself to be former San Francisco Giants pitcher Barry Zito. Yup, looks like we were wrong. After the elimination, the ex-MLB star voiced his appreciation for the show.

“I just had such a great time, and this show has stretched me in so many ways,” Zito said.

So, looks like Night Angel, Turtle and Frog are headed to the finals, baby. And we’re counting down the days.

The Masked Singer returns on Wednesday, May 20, at 8 p.m. PT/ET on Fox.