Scan this QR Code to follow PureWow on Snapchat!
PureWow

*Warning: Spoilers ahead*

Now that Peter Weber is down to four potential matches on The Bachelor, the race to figure out who he ends up with is on. Bachelor fans have been doing everything from trolling the 28-year-old’s Venmo to devising theories about Weber’s potential relationship with a Bachelor producer. The latest theory? Fans are convinced that Weber and contestant Hannah Ann end up together because of two eerily similar Instagram Stories captions.

It started when Weber shared a snap on his Instagram Stories that read, “We be on that island time.”

peter weber island time story
@pilotpete/instagram

Coincidentally, Hannah Ann also used the phrase “island time” on her Instagram Stories around the same time.

hannah ann island time story
@hannahann_sluss

See, she wrote “Island time for me.” What are the chances? 

It’s also worth noting that Bachelor Nation’s Venmo sleuthing has revealed that Hannah Ann is the only Bachelor contestant left with a private Venmo account. (Weber’s is private, too). She also took a photo with a golf bag that bears a striking resemblance to one that Weber has been spotted using.

Does all of this mean Hannah Ann will receive the final rose? According to Reality Steve, not necessarily. As the reality TV blogger noted, the menu in Hannah Ann’s photo is from a restaurant in St. Simons, Georgia, and Weber geo-tagged his location as Saint Croix in the U.S. Virgin Islands. Yep, those are not the same places.

This coincidence suggests that maybe Weber and Hannah Ann are intentionally egging on theorists, which is kind of juicy.

Whatever they’re up to, we can’t wait to see what happens when The Bachelor returns with the hometown episode on Monday, February 17, at 8 p.m. PT/ET on ABC. 

RELATED: We Think We Know the Big ‘Bachelor’ Finale Twist & It Involves a Former Bachelorette

From Around The Web

The News—But Only the Fun Stuff—
Delivered Right to Your Inbox.
Subscribe