The Most Amazing Slices of Pizza in NYC, Ranked
Does your favorite make the cut?
On that cold, winter night when it’s sleeting, icy sludge puddles are on every corner, your umbrella breaks and you can't get an Uber, remember this, and this alone:
It’s all worth it for the pizza.
Yep, NYC has the best pies in the entire universe--but not all slices are created equal. So we’ve narrowed it down to the 30 pizzas in the city you absolutely must try. See you at Paulie Gee’s.
30. THE CLAM PIZZA AT FRANNY’S
OK, clams on pizza aren’t for everyone, but if you’re going to order it, it has to be at Franny's. End of discussion.
348 Flatbush Ave. (at Sterling Pl.), Brooklyn; 718-230-0221 or frannysbrooklyn.com
29. THE CAULIFLOWER PIE AT CO.
Jim Lahey of Sullivan St. Bakery fame has brought new wave pizza to NYC with great success. And you know how we feel about cauliflower.
230 Ninth Ave. (at 24th St.); 212-243-1105 or co-pane.com
28. THE ARTICHOKE PIE AT ARTICHOKE BASILLE’S
This thick and creamy slice is divisive among New Yorkers: Some think the hearty artichoke filling is too rich. Others think it's the best thing that's ever happened to pizza. So you'll have to try it for yourself and find out.
Locations in the East Village, Chelsea, Greenwich Village, Astoria and Park Slope; 212-228-2004 or artichokepizza.com
27. THE SICILIAN AT ROSE AND JOE’S ITALIAN BAKERY
Walk past the Italian bread and cookies at this mom-and-pop shop and you’ll find a pizza counter hidden in the back. Go for the corner slice.
2240 31st St. (at Ditmars Blvd.), Queens; 718-721-9422
26. THE NONNA MARIA FROM BLEECKER STREET PIZZA
Named after the owner’s grandma, this Tuscan-style pie features a thin crust with fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara sauce, Parmesan and fresh basil. Simple. Crunchy. Delicious.
69 Seventh Ave. S. (at Commerce St.); 212-924-4466 or bleeckerstreetpizza.com
25. THE FANTASIA AT RIZZO’S FINE PIZZA
Yes, we will partake of this square pie with basil pesto, ricotta, roasted peppers, black olives, marinated mushrooms and mozzarella, thank you.
Locations on the Lower East Side, Upper West Side and Astoria; 646-454-1262 or rizzosfinepizza.com
23. THE MEATBALL PIZZA AT JOHN’S OF BLEECKER STREET
An oldie but goodie. Just don’t try to order a slice--it's pies and pies only.
278 Bleecker St. (at Jones St.); 212-243-1680 or johnsbrickovenpizza.com
22. THE SPICY SPRING PIE AT PRINCE STREET PIZZA
A crispy square slathered with fra diavolo sauce, grated cheese and pepperoni just curling up ever so slightly in the oven? Sold.
27 Prince St. (at Mott St.); 212-966-4100
21. THE CURED BLACK OLIVE PIZZA AT GRIMALDI’S
If pizzerias were TV shows, Grimaldi’s would definitely be Real Housewives--this legendary haunt has been steeped in drama since it first opened in 1990. It’s a huge tourist draw, so be prepared to wait in line.
Locations in Flatiron and Brooklyn; 646-484-5665 or grimaldis-pizza.com
20. THE CHEESE PIE AT JOE AND PAT’S
Yes, we are asking you to trek out to Staten Island for this pizza. Yes, it’s worth it.
1758 Victory Blvd. (at Manor Rd.), Staten Island; 718-981-0887
19. THE SOPPRESSATA PICANTE PIZZA AT MOTORINO
Get a little fancy at this artisanal brick oven pizzeria with gourmet toppings, like spicy soppressata and Brussels sprouts.
Locations in the East Village and Williamsburg; 212-777-2644 or motorinopizza.com
17. THE COUNTRY HAM PIZZA AT BRUNO
Pizza purists, hear us out. The combination of toppings is heavenly (Pawlet, local peach, smoked ham and cured onion), and the pizzaiolaos grind their own flour in the basement. This newbie is definitely a contender.
204 E. 13th St. (at Third Ave.); 212-598-3080 or brunopizzanyc.com
16. THE COLONY PIZZA AT EMILY
Aww, lovebirds Emily and Matt Hyland have poured their hearts into their Clinton Hill shop, and it shows in this ooey, gooey masterpiece with mozzarella, pepperoni, pickled chili and honey.
919 Fulton St. (at Waverly Ave.); 347-844-9588 or pizzalovesemily.com
15. THE SICILIAN AT L&B SPUMONI GARDENS
Now in its fourth generation, this old-school joint is keeping it simple, and it’s obviously working.
2725 86th St. (at W. Tenth St.); 718-449-1230 or spumonigardens.com
14. THE VODKA PIE AT RUBIROSA
This combo of thin crust, not-too-sweet vodka sauce and disks of fresh mozzarella haunts our dreams.
235 Mulberry St. (at Spring St.); 212-965-0500 or rubirosanyc.com
13. THE PEPPERONI AND SAUSAGE PIZZA AT LOMBARDI’S
Originally opened in 1905, the OG is still going strong after a ten-year hiatus and a move down the block in 1994. Just push past the tourists and get in there--you’re a New Yorker, dammit.
32 Spring St. (at Mott St.); 212-941-7994 or firstpizza.com
12. THE IN RICOTTA DA VEGAN AT PAULIE GEE’S
Sure, Paulie Gee’s has a ton of tasty non-vegan options, but this masterpiece with house-made vegan sausage and cashew ricotta dollops is so tasty, it takes the cake--or should we say pie?
60 Greenpoint Ave. (at West St.), Brooklyn; 347-987-3747 or pauliegee.com
11. THE CARBONARA PIE AT MARTA
Pizza topped with bacon, egg, cheese and potatoes? We’re just gonna call this breakfast.
29 E. 29th St. (at Madison Ave.); 212-651-3800 or martamanhattan.com
10. THE LEMON PIE AT KESTÉ PIZZA AND VINO
It sounds weird, but trust us--the tangy combo of smoked mozzarella, basil and lemon is what dreams are made of.
271 Bleecker St. (at Jones St.); 212-243-1500 or kestepizzeria.com
9. THE CHEESE PIE AT JOE’S PIZZA
Nothing fancy here. It’s just an old-school, no-frills New York slice, and sometimes that’s exactly what we’re craving. (OK, most of the time.)
Locations in the West Village and East Village; 212-366-1182 or joespizzany.com
8. THE MARINARA PIZZA AT DON ANTONIO BY STARITA
How do you know a crust is amazing? When they take away the cheese and you don’t even miss it.
309 W. 50th St. (at Ninth Ave.); 646-719-1043 or donantoniopizza.com
7. THE WHITE ALBUM PIE AT SPEEDY ROMEO
This decadent combo of ricotta, provel, pecorino, béchamel and roasted garlic is not for the faint of heart.
376 Classon Ave. (at Greene Ave.); 718-230-0061 or speedyromeo.com
6. THE MARGHERITA PIE AT PIZZA MOTO
To try a bite, you’ll have to dart through a busy intersection and run under the BQE. They really make you earn it--but talk about sweet rewards.
338 Hamilton Ave. (at Mill St.), Brooklyn; 718-734-6686 or pizzamoto.com
5. THE WHITE PIE FROM BEST PIZZA
Hey, it’s right there in the name, so it must be true.
33 Havemeyer St. (at N. Seventh St.), Brooklyn; 718-599-2210 or best.piz.za.com
4. THE MUSHROOM AND PEPPERONI PIE AT PATSY’S PIZZA
The historic coal-oven pizzeria has opened spin-offs all over the city, and we’re still head-over-heels for its thin, crispy crust.
Locations in Midtown, Greenwich Village, Harlem, Chelsea and Park Slope; 212-247-3491 or thepatsyspizza.com
3. THE REGULAR PIE AT DI FARA PIZZA
There’s definitely nothing regular about Domenico DeMarco’s handiwork--the owner has been making each pie to order by himself since 1964.
1424 Ave. J (at 14th St.), Brooklyn; 718-258-1367
2. THE SAUSAGE AND GARLIC PIZZA AT TOTONNO’S PIZZERIA NAPOLITANA
Forget the Cyclone--this hearty, crunchy pie is the real reason to trek out to Coney Island.
1524 Neptune Ave. (at W. 16th St.), Brooklyn; 718-372-8606 or totonnosconeyisland.com
1. THE BEE STING AT ROBERTA’S PIZZA
This epic pie with tomato, mozzarella, soppressata, chili and honey is salty, sweet and spicy in every bite…and it has officially slayed us. You win, Roberta’s, you win.
261 Moore St. (at Bogart St.), Brooklyn; 718-417-1118 or robertaspizza.com