ComScore

My BF Recommended This Gerard Butler Thriller and I Think It's Seriously Underrated

A low-key thriller that makes a big impact

Gerard Butler: Greenland Review
Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

My boyfriend is a total film buff, so he always has the perfect movie recommendations for my niche moods. On a recent date night, I was craving something scary, but not supernatural, jump-scare scary; something that would get my pulse racing but not have me waking up in the middle of the night with a vision of a possessed nun standing in front of my bed. He suggested 2020's Greenland, starring Gerard Butler, but refused to elaborate on what it was about. "Trust me, you'll like it," he said. I definitely did—but to say that it didn't have me waking up in a cold sweat for nights after would be a lie.

I went in totally blind, but when the film started dropping hints (via radio broadcasts in the car, unassuming chatter in the background) about an impending comet "passing by Earth," I quickly saw where it was going. Greenland is indeed an apocalyptic disaster movie, but it's much more subdued than your typical big-budget blockbuster. In fact, while there is plenty of fiery space fragments and bone-chilling footage of cities destroyed, much of the drama and tension comes from the human aspect of a family navigating (and trying to survive) the end of the world.

Butler stars as John Garrity, an architect who is estranged from his wife Allison (played by Deadpool's Morena Baccarin), but comes home to join a "comet watch party" with their son, Nathan, and a bunch of their friends and neighbors. When John starts getting alerts on his phone about being chosen with his family to be moved to a secure location by the government, he starts to realize that this comet wasn't going to be flying past the planet as originally thought. The rest of the film follows John and his wife and son trying to make their way to the shelter in—where else?—Greenland.

The movie was released in December 2020, and honestly, I'm glad I hadn't watched it—or even heard about it—when it first came out. Given that it reignited all of my COVID-era anxiety, even from a safe distance here in 2025, it would have hit a little too close to home back then (no comet pun intended). Still, I'm a bit disappointed that it didn't seem to get the buzz it deserved. While it may not be an action-packed entry to the disaster genre à la San Andreas or Geostorm (which also stars Butler), its quieter, more character-driven approach makes it all the more heart-pounding. Since it felt so true to life, it was easy to think (and stress out) about what I would do in that situation. In fact, I found myself yelling my advice to the characters on screen on more than one occasion.

Greenland has a pretty mid Rotten Tomatoes score—77 percent on the Tomatometer, 63 percent on the Popcornmeter—but I think it deserves a much higher rating. Thankfully, so does the film studio, considering the movie was greenlit for a sequel. Greenland: Migration, starring the same cast, is slated to be released this year. I know I'll be watching—and if you want to split some popcorn, I suggest catching Greenland streaming on Max, stat.


stephanie maida

Senior Commerce Editor

  • Oversees PureWow's coverage of sales and deals, celebrity commerce and new launches across categories
  • Has worked as a writer and editor for 10+ years
  • Studied journalism at New York University