ComScore

I'm Obsessed with Prime's New Ballet Show 'Étoile'—and Yes, It Reminds Me of 'Gilmore Girls'

After all, it's from Amy Sherman-Palladino

Review of Amazon Prime Video's 'Étoile': Ballet dancer at rehearsal
Courtesy of Philippe Antonello for Amazon MGM Studios

As someone who was kicked out of ballet school for staging a coup against the instructor and convincing the rest of the class to follow my lead, I can appreciate the spirit of a rebellious ballerina. (Sure, I was 3 years old at the time, but still.) Needless to say, Prime Video's fairly new series, Étoile, had me hooked from the get-go.

Created by Amy Sherman-Palladino and her husband Daniel Palladino—the very same duo behind hits like The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel and, yes, our beloved Gilmore Girls—the show focuses on the goings-on of two transatlantic ballet companies after they swap their top talent for a season in an attempt to drive up revenue. But don't worry, one need not be familiar with the names "Balanchine" or "Baryshnikov" to enjoy it.

etoile review cheyenne and jack
Courtesy of Philippe Antonello for Amazon MGM Studios

The show follows a delightful ensemble cast between the sun-drenched dance studios of the Metropolitan Ballet at Lincoln Center and the glamorous halls of Le Ballet National in Paris. And while the premise may sound very Center Stage, it really does remind me of the best aspects of Gilmore Girls, not least of all because it features some of my favorite actors from the series, including Kelly Bishop (Mrs. Emily Gilmore herself) and the ever-exasperated (but in a French way) Yanic Truesdale. Rounding out the cast is the chaotically charming Charlotte Gainsbourg, who plays the head of the French ballet, and the—in my opinion—incredibly dreamy Luke Kirby, who runs the company in New York.

But, back to that rebellious dancer I alluded to above. The true étoile (star) of Étoile is Cheyenne Toussaint (played by Lou de Laâge), the world-renowned prima ballerina, who, when she's not leaving audiences awed on stage, is either getting arrested for protesting illegal fishing boats or making choreographers cry. She's gruff, she's unpredictable, she's so French. Truly, a woman after my own heart.

Review of Amazon Prime Video's 'Étoile': Yanic Truesdale, Charlotte Gainsbourg
Courtesy of Philippe Antonello for Amazon MGM Studios

Now, you may be thinking, how does any of this remind me of Gilmore Girls, beyond the fact that the shows have the same creators? Well, there's the aforementioned ensemble cast, full of eccentric characters you can't help but fall in love with (quirky choreographer Tobias Bell gives major Kirk vibes, while budding star Mishi Duplessis feels very early-seasons Rory).

There's also a ton of that fast-paced, whip-smart dialogue signature to the Palladinos, full of pop culture references and perfectly timed kickers. And, of course, we can't forget the romantic storylines and flirtatious tensions that have you wondering "will they or won't they?" à la Luke and Lorelai.

All of the beautiful dancing, balletcore outfits and stunning locations in New York and Paris simply serve as a backdrop for the humor, drama and development of the characters (albeit pretty gorgeous ones). So, no, you don't have to be a ballet fanatic (or to have gotten disciplined in a tutu yourself) to appreciate the fun, witty and heartwarming moments the series is strewn with.

Review of Amazon Prime Video's 'Étoile': Ballet dancers at rehearsal
Courtesy of Philippe Antonello for Amazon MGM Studios

If you're looking for something to watch this weekend, I can't recommend the eight-episode first season enough—especially for fans of Amy Sherman-Palladino. And thankfully, the show has been renewed for a second season, so I'll be practicing my pliés (and French swear words) 'til then.

Étoile is streaming now on Prime Video.

Want all the latest TV recs sent right to your inbox? Click here.


stephanie maida

Senior Commerce Editor

  • Oversees PureWow's coverage of sales and deals, celebrity commerce and new launches across categories
  • Has worked as a writer and editor for 10+ years
  • Studied journalism at New York University