I Finally Watched the Controversial 'And Just Like That' Finale and, Sorry, You're All Wrong About it

I think they nailed it

and just like that finale
Craig Blankenhorn/HBO Max

It's been just over a week since the series finale of And Just Like That... hit HBO Max, and in that time, I've read and heard a lot of thoughts. Annoyingly, none of them have been positive.

And while SJP herself might not care what the haters have to say, I do. Friends have texted about their disappointment with the ending. Social media acquaintances have posted about their anger. Meanwhile I...decided to wait. I gave it some time before I dove in. I've spent decades with these characters—why would I want to rush the ending (a criticism I've heard about the AJLT creators)?

So, after absorbing/ignoring/deflecting the criticism of the show's finale for days, I finally sat down to say farewell to Carrie, Charlotte, Miranda and the rest. And not only did I like the series finale, I found it sweet, significant and satisfying.

sarah jessica parker sarita choudhury
Craig Blankenhorn/HBO Max

First of all, I loved the wedding dress fashion show. Sure, the dresses were beautiful (I've come to expect nothing less from the series), but I found the two conversations—one between Carrie and Seema and the other between Charlotte and LTW—to be particularly poignant.

Seema makes insightful points (and has a moment of self-discovery) as she questions her desire to get married at all—something that's been ingrained in her since she was a little girl. Carrie explains that she got married because Big "chose me"—another point that Seema challenges.

Meanwhile, LTW and Charlotte dive into the challenges of long-term relationships, both concluding that even after it all, they'd still choose marriage to their respective partners. In fact, the convo sends Lisa directly into the arms of her depressed husband, where they essentially renew their vows to one another.

I loved seeing the characters commit themselves to love—their own personal versions of it.

kristin davis nicole ari parker
Craig Blankenhorn/HBO Max

And while much has been made of the "Miranda-cleaning-up-shit" scene, I thought it worked too. It kept things from being wrapped up in a neat bow—instead it was a literal mess. "Shit happens," Miranda says, reminding us that these women won't have "perfect little lives" moving forward.

But most of all, I enjoyed the final moments of the episode. In a not-so-subtle metaphor, we're reminded how Carrie truly is the one person tying them all together. She delivers a pie to each one of them, and then we get to see them enjoy the pie with their partner/family in their final individual appearances. A lovely and very SATC-feeling montage.

And in my favorite final final moment, Carrie dances alone. TBH, I never thought the men in SATC were right for her. They were right for certain segments of her life perhaps, but not forever. It felt wildly fitting that her last typed words were, "The woman realized she was not alone—she was on her own." Brava, Carrie. For such a fascinating and flawed character (who I've followed for years and years) to come to the realization that all she needs is herself just felt right.

and just like that series finale review
Craig Blankenhorn/HBO Max

Do I think we've seen the last of Carrie, Charlotte and Miranda? I'd like to say yes—but I've thought that before only to get a movie, another movie and a belated reboot. We'll see. I'm just glad that the women got the ending they deserved...and I wish them all well.

Want all the latest royal news sent right to your inbox? Click here.



Philip Mutz Headshot

VP, News and Entertainment

  • Oversees news and entertainment content
  • Is an award-winning playwright and has hosted two entertainment podcasts
  • Has 10+ years experience in entertainment coverage and viral media