When Evelyn approaches Betty (Lili Reinhart) about a welcome interview with The Farm, she jumps at the opportunity to see “inside” the cult. The introduction consists of a tour of the premises by Kevin (Casey Cott) and an interrogation by Evelyn, who asks a series of irrelevant questions before saying, “We’ll call you.”
In the meantime, Betty enlists Cheryl (Madelaine Petsch) to go undercover. Cheryl devises a plan in which Evelyn finds her crying in the school bathroom, forcing an invite to The Farm…and it works.
Cheryl’s interview is seen through the eyes of Betty, who stole obtained the audio tapes. Although Cheryl’s questioning starts off ordinary, things take an interesting turn when Edgar enters the room and demands to speak with Cheryl.
When he asks about her late brother Jason (Trevor Stines), who was killed in season one, Cheryl clams up.
“Memories are often painful, but they don’t have to be,” Edgar says. “They can be a path to revival, and I believe The Farm can help you see that.”
When he tells her to follow him, he leads her to a broom closet just as the tapes screech to an end.
At school, Betty tracks down Cheryl and demands to know what Edgar showed her. Cheryl plays coy, refusing to reveal any further details except for the fact that she’s becoming an official member of The Farm. Dun dun dun.