When Underwood meets up with Tayshia in Santa Ana, California, she immediately blindfolds him and encourages him to trust her. She leads him to the car, drives to the beach and reveals they’re going skydiving. Poor Underwood is about to wet his pants.
“God, please help me survive this fall. I still need to lose my virginity,” he says.
Spoiler alert: Everyone survives. On the ground, Tayshia confesses her feelings for Underwood, saying, “I am falling in love with you, and I do appreciate you so much. And I want you to know that.”
Underwood returns the favor and says that he’s falling in love with her, too, and this is getting out of hand.
That night, Tayshia’s dad puts the pressure on Underwood. When they sit down for a conversation, he questions Underwood’s feelings for his daughter.
“Love is a strong word,” her dad says before accusing him of using it as a “default” line. After Underwood reveals that he’s in love with more than one contestant, he proceeds to ask for permission to marry Tayshia.
Her dad shoots him down, saying, “Colton, well, man, you’re laying it on me. I appreciate you manning up, but I just met you. You know what I mean?”
Of course, that all changes later that night when he sits down with Tayshia, who convinces him to change his mind.