When it comes to dating shows, it doesn’t always work out for the couples involved. While The Bachelor and The Bachelorette have a decent number of success stories, we were surprised to learn that BiP actually has a pretty good track record, even with only nine seasons under its belt. Not only did this year’s installment produce multiple engagements, but it also featured a wedding for Kenny Braasch and Mari Pepin.
So, which pairs are going strong? Well, no one from season nine. Aven Jones and Kylee Russell left the beach together as a couple and then later parted ways. The other couples—from Eliza Isichei and Aaron Bryant to Kat Izzo and John Henry Spurlock—recently announced their break ups after getting engaged in the finale.
In honor of the bombshell breakups, here’s a complete list of Bachelor in Paradise couples who managed to make it work—and those who didn’t.
