When it comes to dating shows, it doesn’t always work out for the couples involved. While The Bachelor and The Bachelorette have a decent number of success stories, we were surprised to learn that BiP actually has a pretty good track record, even with only eight seasons under its belt. Not only did the latest installment produce multiple engagements, but it also sparked a few other real-world relationships.
So, which pairs are still together? In honor of Bachelor in Paradise season 9 coming soon, here’s a complete list of BiP couples who managed to make it work—and nine who didn’t.