Travelers falling in love with Sicily is nothing new. Who could resist such a beautiful place with well-preserved ruins, beaches and one of the highest active volcanoes in Europe? Thanks to the second season of White Lotus, everyone seems to be buzzing about the largest Mediterranean island more than ever (especially the resort where the season was filmed, Four Seasons San Domenico Palace). But, if you’re looking to live the Sicilian dream for a few days but don’t necessarily feel like dealing with the tourism surge or sky-high prices, consider these less trendy—though equally alluring—stand-ins that deliver a taste of the sweet life.