Here’s Why Fans Think They Already Know Who Wins ‘The Bachelor’

*Warning: Spoilers ahead*

Peter Weber has officially wrapped filming season 24 of The Bachelor. While ABC has tried to keep spoilers under wraps, fans are convinced they know who wins the upcoming installment.

Here’s what you need to know: Production on Weber’s season of the popular dating series recently concluded, which means the 28-year-old star regained access to his cell phone. (Weber wasn’t allowed to use any form of technology while filming the show.)

In addition to sharing a selfie with his dog, Weber also went on a following spree. Of course, he didn’t follow any of the contestants—because that would be obvious. He did, however, give us several hints about what’s to come.

Shortly after Weber’s return to Instagram, one private fan account (@BachSleuthers) pointed out that he followed a few vegan pages, which is totally out of character.

After more digging, @BachSleuthers found a contestant that fits the profile: Victoria Fuller. Not only is she dedicated to the plant-based lifestyle, but she also follows multiple vegan accounts on Instagram and regularly shares recipe ideas on her Pinterest account.  

If the name “Victoria Fuller” sounds familiar, it’s probably because she was the center of a recent controversy. It all started when Weber invited the contestant on a one-on-one date to Cedar Point, a theme park located in Sandusky, Ohio.

The problem? The outing involved a surprise concert by Chase Rice, who just so happens to be Fuller’s ex-boyfriend. In the behind-the-scenes videos obtained by Reality Steve, the contestant can be seen awkwardly dancing with Weber before dragging him out of the venue. Fuller was later seen complaining to producers, so ready thy popcorn.

Did Fuller inspire Weber’s follow spree? Or is it a complete coincidence? Either way, she’s going at the top of our bracket.

Season 24 of The Bachelor premieres on January 6.