Bachelor Nation Is Convinced Madison Prewett Is Dating ‘BiP’ Star Connor Saeli

Sorry, Peter Weber. It appears Madison Prewett is setting her eyes on a brand-new dating prospect: Connor Saeli, who appeared on Hannah Brown’s season of The Bachelorette and season six of Bachelor in Paradise.

Random, right? We couldn’t agree more, but the evidence speaks volumes. It all started over the weekend when Connor hosted an Instagram Live Q&A with his former co-star, Mike Johnson. While discussing the upcoming season of BiP, Mike implied that Connor has a crush on Madison.  

“So, what’s up with you and Madison?” Mike asked.

Connor nervously responded, “I don’t know, we’ll see. I can’t give you anything.”

Mike also inquired about Connor’s involvement with Bachelor in Paradise, asking if it would be contingent on Madison joining the cast.

“If a certain individual goes [to paradise], would you go?” Mike asked. To which Connor said, “Sure…it was tough going on last year and having it not work for me in the end. It was a little disappointing to see all the happy couples.”

According to an E! News source, Connor reportedly sent Madison a direct message after The Bachelor finale. Although we don’t know if she responded, Connor’s reaction to Mike’s question is probably the closest thing we’ll get to an answer.

That’s one BiP pairing we can highlight on our list of potential cast members.