Kelley Flanagan Calls Out Peter Weber for Not Choosing Her on ‘The Bachelor’: ‘I Should Sue Him'

Kelley Flanagan is about to go all Elle Woods on Bachelor Peter Weber.

The 27-year-old tax attorney, who’s currently social distancing with her former ex in her Chicago apartment, poked fun at the fact that they broke up on The Bachelor and low-key threatened legal action.

It all started while Weber was filming a Cameo video to wish someone a happy birthday.

“I heard there was a rumor or something that you guys thought that I was like quarantined with a Chicago property tax lawyer, I’m not quite—” the 28-year-old pilot joked as Flanagan walked to the fridge in the frame behind him. “What the hell is that? What? Where’d you come from?” he said, reacting to Flanagan “surprising” him.

Flanagan came over to hug Weber from behind and said, “Hi Lexi! Hey, I heard that you’re an attorney as well, and it looks like great minds think alike. And to be honest I think both you and I should sue him for not choosing me!” Uh-oh.

Weber chimed in saying, “OK, this just got weird. What? No. I’m wishing her a happy birthday. Don’t listen to her!”

Flanagan wished Lexi (not the one from the show, don’t worry) a happy birthday and Weber ended the video by saying “Lawyers” and shaking his head.

Weber and Flanagan, who swear they’re not dating and are “taking it really, really slow,” have been living together since March.

Let’s just hope Flanagan holds off on the legal action until they can return to their respective homes.

Shop the Best of 'The Bachelor' Style:


Cat mom, yogi, brunch enthusiast

Lex is an LA native who's deeply obsessed with picnics, Slim Aarons, rosé, Hollywood history and Joan Didion. She joined PureWow in early 2017.