The episode opens on the camp cook (Lily Rabe) chatting with her two children slash campers—Bobby and Benjamin (aka young Mr. Jingles). The mom is frustrated because she wants her kids to take advantage of the camp activities—after all, she took the job just for them.
When Bobby suggests swimming, Benjamin is hesitant but agrees. Outside, Benjamin sees the lifeguard sneaking off into the woods with a girl, so he follows to watch from afar.
Meanwhile, Bobby gets into the water…with no lifeguard on duty. When an oncoming boat approaches, the driver doesn’t see the swimmer and drives directly over Bobby, ultimately killing him.
After pulling his mangled body from the water, the mom immediately blames Benjamin.
“What the hell, Benjamin?” she says. And then adds, “You killed my baby.”