Last (but not least), Caelynn joins Harrison onstage. She’s in tears after watching a video recapping her time on the show, claiming “it’s not easy to see.”
You see, she thought she had “met her person.” So, she’s been overanalyzing every episode trying to find evidence that he did, in fact, love her. She doesn’t understand how they can go from meeting her family to “nothing.”
When Caelynn returns to the group, Underwood comes out and takes a seat next to Harrison. Caelynn asks when he knew that she wasn’t the one, and Underwood reveals that it all came down to the rose ceremony.
He apologizes to the group for hurting anyone’s feelings, which prompts Sydney to address the elephant in the room.
“Are you still a virgin?” she asks.
He doesn’t answer. In fact, he beats around the bush and asks Sydney a question instead. Sketchy, indeed.
When Harrison presses him about the infamous fence jump, Underwood reveals that it was a result of Cassie not reciprocating his feelings.
At long last, the host brings us to our favorite part of The Women Tell All: the bloopers. After playing a clip featuring behind-the-scenes fails (“nailed it!”), the host teases a sneak peek of next week’s finale that proves yesterday’s drama is only the beginning.
The Bachelor returns to ABC for a two-night finale beginning Monday, March 11, at 8 p.m.