The 18 Best New Valentine’s Day Foods, Drinks & Candy to Get You Psyched for Feb. 14th

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and the company may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

Pink and red hearts are decorating store aisles, and it won’t be long before you need to order a bunch of sweets—and perforated, Hello Kitty or Spidey-adorned cards—for your kids’ classmates. If you really want to impress ‘em this year, opt for something they haven’t seen before. And get everyone in on the season of love with some delightfully cheesy (sometimes literally) foods that feel right on theme. Behold, the best new Valentine’s Day candy—and foods and drinks—to stock up on this year.

The 40 Best Valentine’s Day Cookies to Make with Your Family

1. ‘Friends’ Conversation Hearts

We all know somebody who can quote just about every line from Friends. For that person, these candies are a must this Valentine’s Day. They feature 26 nods the series, like “UR MY LOBSTR,” “on a break” and “how you doin’?” So—like shouting “pivot!” any time you move furniture—they’re basically impossible to resist.

2. Gummy Lunchables Hearts

While it’s mildly upsetting to consider that gummy Lunchables are pretty much the same consistency as the meat and cheese in regular Lunchables, you have to admit…these treat boxes are pretty funny. And nostalgic. Was there anything more romantic in the second grade than someone willing to split their pepperoni pizza Lunchable with you?!

3. White Chocolate Strawberry Shake M&M’s

Ah, little bites of milkshake in candy-coated, snackable form. We don’t blame you if you don’t want to share.

4. ‘Encanto’ Gummy Rings

Fact: The best Valentine’s Day cards were ones that included candy. Unlike Bruno, your kids will be the talk of the cafeteria when they roll up with Encanto-themed ones, which come with very Mirabel and Isabela-inspired gummy rings.

5. Godiva 14-Piece Chocolate Heart Gift Box

Assorted chocolates can be hit or—let’s face it—mostly miss. Not so with Godiva’s assortment. Its 14-piece box features an array of milk, dark and white chocolate, with the occasional raspberry-, praline- or caramel-filled treat thrown in to keep things interesting. There’s not a bad bite to be found.

6. Welch’s Juicefuls Heartthrobs

Millennials, prepare to meet Gen Z’s answer to Gushers: Welch’s Juicefuls. This riff is heart-shaped, and the juice-filled fruit snacks are cherry and strawberry-flavored, making them a perfect V-day treat that feels semi-virtuous (real fruit is the first ingredient, after all, and they’re free of the eight major allergens).

7. Jet-Puffed Strawberry Marshmallows

Your cup of hot cocoa just got so much more festive. The strawberry flavor is mild, adding just a touch of fruity sweetness, so it won’t overpower your drink–or whatever you serve ‘em with.

8. Dark Chocolate Balsamic Vinegar

Described as “adult chocolate syrup,” this sauce adds a sweet-yet-tangy touch to anything it’s added to. Might we suggest using it as an unexpected topping for ice cream or fruit?

9. Sugar Lab Peppermint Mocha Valentine Bonbons

Nope, those aren’t lattes for Barbies—they’re actual peppermint mocha bonbons. Sugar Lab 3D prints peppermint-flavored sugar into the shape of a coffee cup, then fills it with espresso-dark chocolate ganache. Each six-pack is good for 12 weeks, but we doubt they’ll last that long on your kitchen counter.

10. David’s Tea Cupid’s Breakfast Tea

Instead of bergamot, this variation on Cream of Earl Gray features rose, giving it a light, floral flavor. It’s a dreamier twist on your morning cup that feels fitting for Feb. 14th (or any day that could use a little oomph, honestly).

11. Three Wishes Chocolate-Covered Strawberry Cereal

Round out that morning routine with a decadent-sounding, uh, cereal. Three Wishes, makers of high-protein, low-sugar, gluten-free cereals has brought back its limited-edition Valentine’s Day treat: chocolate-covered strawberry O’s. They’re made from chickpeas, instead of grains, and reviewers rave that it’s equally good in milk or atop yogurt.

12. Ben & Jerry’s and Tony’s Chocolonely Chocolatey Love A-Fair

Chocoholics, this one’s for you. Ben & Jerry’s partnered with Tony’s Chocolonely to create a custom pint of ice cream (and two limited-edition chocolate bars, one dark milk chocolate brownie bar and a white chocolate strawberry cheesecake bar). But let’s focus on the ice cream: It’s a decadent blend of chocolate ice cream with salted caramel swirls, gobs of caramel and chunks of sea salt fudge. Trust us when we say you’ll want to start stalking your grocery store’s freezer section for this one.

13. ‘You’re My Lover’ Sugar Cookies

OK, so Taylor Swift concert tickets were nearly impossible to snag; but you can splurge on your most Midnights-obsessed friend with these cookies from NYC’s Funny Face Bakery. They can be shipped nationwide, and if Taylor isn’t your cup of tea, you can also confess your love with a Yoda, Harry Styles or custom-designed treat.

14. Hershey’s Chocolate-Dipped Strawberry Kisses

These milk chocolate Kisses have a sweet strawberry filling, making them the budget-friendly, low-effort way to indulge in the flavors of a classic Feb. 14th treat without having to deal with tempering chocolate and all that.

15. Loverboy Date Night Duo

While you could mix up your own V-day cocktails, you could also give yourself a break and pick up the Loverboy Date Night Duo. The pack comes with eight canned cocktails—four espresso martinis and four cosmopolitans—each at 12 percent ABV and less than 4 grams of sugar per serving. Pro tip: Pour the Cosmo over ice and add a spritz of lime to take it to the next level.

16. Old Flame Breakable Heart Decorating Kit

If you’re looking to go the DIY route this Valentine’s Day, Fancy Sprinkles has you covered with a complete kit to make 7-inch chocolate hearts, including molds, shimmery edible prism powder, festive sprinkles and a wooden mallet to smash it to bits when you’re ready to dig in.

17. Favorite Day Pink Chocolate Chip Pancakes

You could pour pancake batter into cookie cutters and make heart-shaped flapjacks. To that end, you could even fold your kids’ napkins into origami flowers, just to show how much you care. But we think they’d be equally delighted with this low-effort, high-reward mix, which makes fluffy, lightly pink-hued pancakes studded with chocolate chips. Your call.

18. Prospector Popcorn Sweethearts Pack

This trio of flavors could serve as teachers’ gifts this Valentine’s Day, though you may want to order a second set to keep to yourself. (Just being honest.) The Sweethearts Pack features bags of caramel popcorn along with its Belgian Chocolate Toffee and Strawberry Chocolate varieties (the latter is studded with freeze-dried strawberries, as well as a white chocolate drizzle). What’s even cooler, though, is Prospector Popcorn’s commitment to offering equal, competitive employment opportunities to people with disabilities, who compose 74 percent of the company’s workforce.

The 73 Best Valentine’s Day Desserts You’ll Swoon Over

Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

Candace Davison

VP of editorial, recipe developer, kitsch-lover

Candace Davison oversees PureWow's food and home content, as well as its franchises, like the PureWow100 review series and the Happy Kid Awards. She’s covered all things lifestyle...
read full bio

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.