You’re throwing a little Halloween get-together, but you’re trying to walk the fine line between festive and fake-finger-in-your-drink tacky. No worries, girls and ghouls—here are 45 Halloween cocktails to serve at your soirée, from a Honeycrisp Crush to a Black Widow Smash. They’re seasonal, not too kitschy and—dare we say?—scary delicious. (Mwahaha.)

RELATED: 21 Halloween Dinner Ideas for Adults

1. Sleepy Hollow Cocktail

Pomegranate, tequila and rosemary-orange syrup make this the ideal pairing for a scary movie.

Get the recipe

2. Maple New York Sour

The red wine float is what makes this one different from a regular whiskey sour.

Get the recipe

3. Pomegranate Cider Mimosas with a Salted Caramel Rim

Who needs to steal from the kids’ candy hauls when you have a salted caramel rim?

Get the recipe

4. Witches Brew Drink

You’ll have everyone chanting “double, double, toil and trouble” after one sip of this Midori-based beverage.

Get the recipe

5. Nightmare on Bourbon Street

It’s like a bourbon smash but with ginger and cinnamon for a warming, cozy effect.

Get the recipe

6. Smoky Cider Mezcal Margarita

The smokiness of the mezcal balances the sweetness of the cider to a T.

Get the recipe

7. Apple Cider Mimosa

Is Halloween brunch a thing? If not, we’re making it one.

Get the recipe

8. Pumpkin Spice Kentucky Mule

Swapping the usual vodka for bourbon makes it a Kentucky mule. Make one after you’re done with your thousandth PSL of the season.

Get the recipe

9. Spiced Apple Cider Margaritas

If you’re serving a crowd, feel free to make these sweet and spicy cocktails in a big batch.

Get the recipe

10. Chai Cocktail

It’s made with golden raisin-infused rum and homemade vanilla chai simple syrup—fancy.

Get the recipe

11. Ginger Apple Moscow Mule

If you’re more about fuzzy sweaters and apple picking than scary movies and haunted houses, this not-too-spooky cocktail has your name on it.

Get the recipe

12. Spiced Bourbon Punch

No costume party is complete without a bowl of Champagne-spiked punch.

Get the recipe

13. Honey Roasted Pear Sparkling Cocktails

If you’re already sick of apples, might we suggest pears instead? (Psst: This one doubles as a mocktail.)

Get the recipe

14. Maple Old Fashioned

Luxardo cherries > king-size candy bars.

Get the recipe

15. Honey Vodka and Apple Cider Hot Toddy

If you’re not drinking this by a crackling fire (or fire pit), you’re doing it wrong.

Get the recipe

16. Adult Hot Chocolate

There’s bourbon, Frangelico and homemade Irish cream. Serve this up when the kids go to bed.

Get the recipe

17. Honeycrisp Crush

Every year, we wait for the arrival of Honeycrisps, aka the ideal apples. They’re sweet-tart, crisp and refreshing, so it’s only natural that they make a stellar cocktail. This one has ginger beer and vodka for a little kick.

Get the recipe

18. Boozy Pumpkin Pie Shooters

This is just a test round for your Thanksgiving feast.

Get the recipe

19. La Cura

If a mezcalita and a Penecillin had a delicious baby, this smoky-sour cocktail would be it.

Get the recipe

20. Pumpkin Patch Punch

Here’s proof that you can be kitschy and cute without going too over the top. This vodka- and brandy-based punch is spicy and autumnal, but has plenty of bright and zesty citrus to balance it out.

Get the recipe

21. Thyme Apple Cider Spritz

In a word, yum. It’s like a rosé spritz put on a giant scarf and oversize sweater for the season.

Get the recipe

22. Black Velvet Cocktail

This cocktail gets its sultry color from a mix of crème de cassis and stout beer.

Get the recipe

23. The Black Widow Smash

Another looker, this five-minute drink contains a blend of blackberries and mezcal for a smoky-sweet concoction that’s just festive enough.

Get the recipe

24. Bourbon Ginger Cider Cocktails

There’s nothing spooky about these fall drinks. (You can even make a batch ahead of time if you’re having company.)

Get the recipe

25. Pumpkin Fizz Cocktail

The color? On point. The flavor? Delightfully seasonal. Yep, we’re serving this at our Halloween party.

Get the recipe

26. Homemade Horchata with Pumpkin Seeds, Maple and Ginger

Horchata is to fall as eggnog is to winter. Bonus, this one’s totally vegan.

Get the recipe

27. Pumpkin Smash Cocktail

If we’re being totally honest, we’re here for the candied cinnamon pumpkin seeds.

Get the recipe

28. The Half Blood Prince Cocktail

Something wicked (wickedly beautiful, that is) this way comes.

Get the recipe

29. Sparkling Apple Cider Sangria

This mocktail is light-years ahead of the usual fruit-juice-and-seltzer concoction we settle for.

Get the recipe

30. Dark and Stormy in the Pumpkin Patch

Classic cocktail, but make it festive. Spiced rum and ginger beer are the stars in this drink, with pumpkin and orange for good measure.

Get the recipe

31. Haunted Orchard Cocktail

It has tequila, so yeah, you could say it’s haunted.

Get the recipe

32. Boozy Pumpkin White Hot Chocolate

Pick your poison: Kahlua or bourbon.

Get the recipe

33. Apple Butter Old Fashioned

Don’t save this one just for Halloween. We’re making it our go-to cocktail for all of fall.

Get the recipe

34. Fig Bourbon Cider Smash

Out with the frosé, in with the cider. This fall beauty boasts fig preserves, orange zest and balsamic vinegar.

Get the recipe

35. Pumpkin Pineapple Cocktail

This cocktail combines three delicious seasonal offerings: pumpkin puree, dark rum and spices. Ooh, and it only takes five minutes to make.

Get the recipe

36. Honeycrisp and Bourbon Spiced Cider

Apple slices and star anise make for the most gorgeous garnish.

Get the recipe

37. Cranberry-Spiced Whiskey Sour

The key is homemade cranberry simple syrup spiced with cinnamon, cloves and orange peel and sweetened with maple syrup.

Get the recipe

38. Poison Apple Martini

Set these out for your guests and you've got yourself a brouhaha fit for a witch.

Get the recipe

39. Monsteritas

These healthy(ish) margaritas are loaded with cucumber, jalapeño and coconut cream.

Get the recipe

40. Halloween Sangria

Frozen grape “eyeballs” give this sophisticated sipper just the right amount of Halloween spirit.

Get the recipe

41. Cranberry Margarita

Lemon-lime soda offers this tart cocktail some devilishly sweet relief.

Get the recipe

42. Hard Apple Cider Mule

Prime for sipping while lounging in a pile of crunchy leaves.

Get the recipe

43. Ruby Vermouth Spritzers

Think of this as the autumnal version of an Aperol spritz.

Get the recipe

44. Smoked Whiskey Apple Cider Cocktail

Smoked tea and your liquor of choice (aged rum! bourbon! whiskey!) pull this lush libation together.

Get the recipe

45. Hot Buttered Rum

This tastes like fall in a glass. Don’t forget the cinnamon sticks for stirring.

Get the recipe

RELATED: 16 Non-Tacky Halloween Party Recipes That Your Guests Will Love

From Around The Web