purewow100 | fashion

No More Pants Hemming for This Petite—Here's My Review of the Short Story Subscription Box

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and the company may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. You can learn more about that process here.

  • Quality: 17/20
  • Value: 18/20
  • Curation: 20/20
  • Fit: 18/20
  • Convenience: 19/20

Total 92/100

Recently I learned that half the adult women in the U.S. are 5’3.5” or shorter, the common definition of petite. So why are we hard-pressed to find clothes that actually fit a petite frame?

As a 5’4” woman who’s always rolling up her pants and tucking in long shirt tails lumpily into her trousers, I had pretty much given up on the idea of ever having off-the-rack styles fit—until I came across Short Story, the clothing subscription box that curates styles for women 5’4” and below.

To get started, I answered a few questions like: What’s your height, weight and age? What items do you have the most trouble finding the right fit for? What’s your preferred price range for tops, bottoms, coats or jackets—under $50, $50 to $100 or $100+? There were also a few prompts to gauge my aesthetic preferences like: “Please react to these outfit collages (edgy romantic, laid-back casual, boho, modern chic)." All in all, it’s a pretty short quiz that took me about four minutes to complete in one sitting (though you do have the option to save your results and finish it later if you need more time).

The 15 Best Joggers for Short Women, According to a Shortie Stylist and Opinionated Petites

Dana Dickey

1. The Perfectly Oversized Everyday Buttondown

When I received my box ten days later, I hurriedly tore into it to try on the five selected garments and almost missed the personalized love letter from my stylist, Courtney. She wrote “as a petite gal myself, I know how difficult it can be to find the perfect fit…I noticed quite a few button downs on your Pinterest, so this one, the Edison Oversized Poplin Shirt ($68), caught my eye for you.” Shout out to you Court, I. Feel. Seen.

What’s unique about this white button down from the 17 others in my closet is that it has the proportional untucked volume you want without the sloppy length in the sleeves or the body.

So, the shirt, j’adore. I slipped it on with the Madison Front Seam Texture Pants ($68), which felt, just wrong. When I pulled the waist to its correct height, the length was a tad too short—bad news for me, but good news for anyone under 5’4”.

Dana Dickey

2. The Proportional Maxi Dress

The printed peasant dress was a real wild card for me, and far more bohemian than I’d usually try, but since I’d just watched Daisy Jones & the Six, I was all in. Also, the design has an underbust cinched empire waist, again not my go-to silhouette, but here the design gave the illusion of longer legs, instead of emphasizing my superlong Gumby waist. I’m a bit shy about wearing low necklines, so I probably won’t be keeping this dress, but I’m here for the style education it gave me.

Dana Dickey

3. The Well-Cropped Army Green Trousers

The slubby yarn top ($88) was pretty and fit me well, but again, it exposed a little too much skin for my liking. The Relaxed Grace Pant ($78), however, was like meeting a soulmate, but you know, in olive drab cotton. It’s the perfect length to wear with flat sandals and sneakers without having to roll it up. And the hem is frayed, but in that gently fuzzed way I’m never able to replicate when I try to do it at home. The medium rise isn’t so low that it’s going to prevent me from moving around, and the fabric quality and simple cut of the pants are versatile enough to wear with a dressy blouse and heels (or more likely a pair of Havaianas and a white T-shirt).

Overall, the Short Story experience was better than I’d hoped. The personal shopper element proved to be valuable and well worth the $25 you pay for the stylist's work putting together each box, which is deducted from the price of your purchases. And now that I know it’s unlikely that I’ll purchase every piece from each box, I’ll amend my price guidelines to the $100+ range, since I’m trying to buy fewer pieces of better quality. Which brings me to the only quibble I have with the box: I wasn’t thrilled with the synthetic feel of the cotton knit top and there was a loose thread on the dress. But that quality issue is far from a deal-breaker, and most likely a reflection of the under $100 price point-per-item I initially chose.

One last note: You have five days to decide what to keep and return, which is two days more than Stitch Fix and the same as Daily Look (two competing subscription boxes). As for frequency, you can change the cadence to however often or seldom you’d like to receive a box. So, no pressure.

I’m glad I discovered Short Story, because I’ll be hitting them up for a seasonal infusion of style inspo every few months, as well as asking for help whenever there are any special occasions I want to have the perfect fit for.

Shop More Petite Styles

Flattering Wide-Leg Pants

Madewell Petite Harlow Wide-Leg Pant 

The Breeziest Dress

Banana Republic Isa Cotton-Silk Dress

The Statement Top

Maeve Cutout Lace Short-Sleeve Buttondown Shirt

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow is the best friend you never had when it comes to finding the best, most useful lifestyle products online. Founded in 2010, our company’s editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which ones are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series, which sees each and every item we test being ranked on a 100-point scale of awesomeness, to the painstakingly curated lists our fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family editors create as vertical experts, you can trust that our recommendations include some of the greatest items you’ll find on the internet. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.

The 20 Best Jeans for Short Women, According to the Petite People Who Wear Them