No one’s better at unleashing his inner Pavarotti and laying down some sick Broadway beats than Carpool Karaoke king James Corden, right? Not according to Neil Patrick Harris, who stopped by The Late Late Show to settle the score once and for all. The Tony winners faced off with songs from Hamilton, Les Miserables, Company, Chicago and Hedwig and the Angry Inch—and things got so heated, NPH returned after the commercial break to admit he accidentally ripped his pants during the sultry serenade. Sorry, James. We love you, but NPH totally wins this round; jazz hands included.