After watching 24 seasons (and counting) of The Bachelor, it’s hard not to picture ourselves as the fame-seeking contestants, who will do anything—we repeat, anything—to get the star’s attention…even if it means stealing a years-old bottle of Champagne. We get so invested that sometimes we wonder who we’d be a good match for if we were on the show. Would we end up with Peter Weber? How about Colton Underwood? Or—dare we say—Arie Luyendyk Jr.? Take the quiz below to find out which season of The Bachelor you’d totally win.